way,â Courtney replied. âThe cookies are just mud. Iâll prove it to you. Iâll do something to Maryjoâs cookie. Nothing will happen. Youâll see.â
Courtney and I hurried up to her room. She pulled the Maryjo cookie from its hiding place in the dresser drawer. She set it down on her desk. âLetâs see. What should we do to it?â she asked.
She didnât wait for me to answer. She picked up a pair of scissors, and âsnip snipâ cut off all the yellow hair.
I gazed at the cookie with its ragged, bald head. Then I shoved the phone into my sisterâs hand. âGo ahead. Call her.â
Courtneyâs eyes went wide. âCall Maryjo?â
âYes. Call her,â I insisted. âSee if anything happened.â
Courtney punched in Maryjoâs number. âHi, Mrs. Rawlins. Itâs Courtney. Is Maryjo there?â she asked.
Courtneyâs mouth dropped open. She suddenly turned pale. âOh. I see,â she said. âWellâ¦no problem. It wasnât important. Hope Maryjo is okay.â She clicked off the phone.
âWhat? What? â I asked.
Courtney slumped onto the edge of her bed. Her voice came out in a whisper. âIâI could hear Maryjo screaming. Her mom said she couldnât come to the phone. She was having some kind of trouble with her hair.â
I gulped. âYou could hear her screaming?â
Courtney nodded. âShe was yelling, âMy hairâitâs falling out! Help me! Itâs all falling out!ââ
I stared at the bald cookie on the desk. I suddenly felt sick. My legs were trembling. âWeâwe have to tell Mom,â I said.
I turned and started toward the bedroom doorway. Momâs voice floated up from downstairs. âIâm going, kids. Iâm meeting your dad for dinner in town. Lulu is here. Come down and say hi.â
Lulu?
Courtney and I both froze. âIâm not going down there,â Courtney whispered. âSheâs too scary. She has powers. She made us do horrible things.â
âWe have to go down,â I said. âWe have to tell Lulu the truth. That we donât want to hurt our friends.â
âI can hear you up there!â Lulu shouted. âCome down, you two.â
Courtney and I made our way down the stairs, clinging to the banister as if it were a life raft. Lulu stood in the living room, arms crossed, waiting for us.
She was dressed in black again, a black sweater pulled down over a short black skirt. A long purple scarf that matched her lipstick was curled around her neck.
âThere you are!â she exclaimed, smiling.
âWe know the truth about the mud cookies,â I blurted out in a trembling voice. âWe donât think itâs right to hurt people.â
A smile spread over Luluâs face. âItâs not rightâbut it sure is fun, isnât it?â
âNo,â Courtney said. âItâs not fun. Weâre telling. Weâre telling my parents about it as soon as they get home.â
âNo, youâre not,â Lulu replied softly. Her smile faded slowly. âYouâre not telling anyone. Let me show you why.â
She lifted the lid off a square white box beside her on the coffee table. She pulled out two mud cookies and held them up, one in each hand.
Her eyes lit up. âSee? I made Matthew and Courtney cookies!â
âOh no!â I gasped. The Matthew cookie had black hair and a skinny body, just like me. The Courtney cookie was thin and wiry, like Courtney.
âNo more talk about telling on me. Letâs get busy,â Lulu said, holding the cookies in front of her. âWe need mud, guys. Weâre going to bake some more special cookies today.â
âNo way!â I cried. âYou canât force usââ
Lulu plucked a white feather from a couch pillow. A grin spread over her face as she slowly raised the quill of the feather to