lifted snarls of ginger curls around her shoulders. âHe said itâs a trial separation. And that I shouldnât ask about it.â
âAnd how are you doing on that?â
âYeah, Joe accidentally put the hydro bill into a recycling bin instead of a mailbox yesterday. I donât obey him on principle. Am I getting dinner tonight?â
Theo willed his ribcage to expand with air, then contract to press out all the frustration and tension and rage. Heâd been doing Raeâs yoga DVDs after the kids were asleep, but by then he was so exhausted he might not quite have had it right.
âThereâs, yeah, some scalloped turnips in the fridge, just microwaveâem. And tofu steaks from the weekend, if you want. The kids will probably just want the turnips, but give them the tofu if they ask.â
Colleen put her face on her knees. âThe kids will want scalloped turnips ?â
âItâs a free meal, Colleen.â
She raised her head, suddenly bright and interested. âAre we going to argue?â
âWhat?â
âYou sounded . . . exasperated. If Iâm mean, will you be mean back?â
âI wasnât being mean, I just didnât want you to â â
âYeah yeah yeah. Better than Joe, just sitting there like a lump of â â
âThatâs why you threw the shoe? Because your father is an insufficient debater?â
âHe didnât even make a sound when it hit him. Thatâs how I know it didnât hurt.â
âThatâs not a way to know. Especially with Joe.â
âSheâs not coming , you know. This is a joke.â
He sighed, and then tried to make the sigh into a yoga breath. âYou canât make me angry, and you canât make me think Rae wonât come. People get held up at work. Buses get stuck. Those are reasonable explanations. And there are others.â
âNot for why she wouldnât have called and used two 3-cent cellphone minutes to tell you that.â
âThere might be something wrong with the â â
âThere isnât. Just for argumentâs sake say there isnât.â
âFine. But how do you explain why sheâd ask me to dinner and then not come?â
âCruelty?â
âSeparation doesnât mean Rae hates me. Even divorce wouldnât mean that.â
âDoesnât have to have hate involved. Might not even be about you, or anyone. Some people are just naturally cruel.â
âRae is not cruel,â he said fast and involuntarily, words expelled like the whoosh of breath that would have come out had Colleen punched him in the stomach.
âNo?â
âMarley, sit down. It wonât work if you do that.â
The children were at the backyard gate, almost behind the porch. Marley was flopped forward over her chair-bar, with Jake in front of her, a long stick in his right hand, drawn up
as if to stab. But of course he would not do that. Theo gathered himself to speak sharply, to take the stick away, to parent.
Without turning her eyes from Marley and Jake, Colleen murmured, âDo you think Iâm cruel?â
Theo froze half-standing, in a kind of pre-modern hunch. âCruel?â
âBecause I threw a shoe at my father, who is basically a nice person that just doesnât know what the hell is going on? Should I just have let him be, in his ignorance?â
Theo felt his shoulders relax, let himself sink back onto the step. He suddenly knew what to say. âI do think you should have let him be. Because the punishment didnât educate him, did it? There should only be punishment when it has the capacity to reform. Otherwise itâs just energy wasted, pain â cruelty. Joe learned nothing about your wish for privacy from that shoe, so nothing was gained. You were cruel.â
Colleen seemed to slip backwards without actually moving, shrink into herself. But then she said, âSo
Jason Padgett, Maureen Ann Seaberg