planters’ crops in the
area that year, Bell’s cotton, tobacco, and corn crops
failed. The financial impact of this crop failure forced
Bell to sell several slaves in order to have money to
live on until the next crop season. Between crop
seasons, John and Lucy Bell had more bad luck –
the mules died of colic, and the cows and hogs
became sick with an incurable disease. Bell was
forced to sell even more slaves, keeping only a few for
the next crop season.
Money was now a major concern for the Bells, as
were several buildings on the farm that were in bad
need of repair. To that end, the Bells’ future and
livelihood depended solely on the next crop season.
Despite fervid prayer and much hard work, the crop
season once again failed miserably.
Against his will, Bell decided to sell the farm to
another planter, William Rawls, and move to the new
land in the west and start over. 8 This was no easy
decision, especially for a man of Bell’s strong pride
and character.
7 Source does not wish to be disclosed.
8 Halifax County, North Carolina, Deed Book 19 , p.164.
THE BELL WITCH: THE FULL ACCOUNT
27
The Bells Leave North Carolina
Over the years leading up to the farm’s downfall,
John and Lucy Bell received letters from many
friends who had moved to the western lands from
North Carolina. Several of these families, such as
the Forts and Gunns, settled in middle Tennessee
near the Red River at the edge of an area known as
the “Barren Plains.” In their letters, they described
this land as being the most beautiful and fertile land
anywhere, yielding plentiful returns for the many
families who emigrated from the east.
Elias Fort had been a clerk with the Tar River
Association, a religious advocacy group in North
Carolina that included John and Lucy Bell’s church.
Soon after arriving in the new land, Fort and two
other clergymen successfully started a Baptist
church in the Red River area. Given the opportunity
to be reunited with old friends, and to start a new
farm in an area known for its fertility, John and Lucy
Bell decided to move their family to this land.
In the winter of 1803-1804, John Bell and his
family set out across the mountains of North
Carolina and east Tennessee, on their way to middle
Tennessee. They settled in the Red River bottomland
area, located in what is now the western end of
Robertson County, Tennessee. The travel party was
large, consisting of John and Lucy Bell, and their
children, Jesse, John Jr., Drewry, Esther, and
Zadok.
Along with their family, John and Lucy Bell
brought several slaves, including a woman named
Chloe and her son, Dean. Dean played a big role in
getting the Bell family from North Carolina to
Tennessee safely, and later became the most
valuable slave on the Bell plantation.
28 P A T
F I T Z H U G H
CHAPTER TWO
The Bells’ New Home
T HE BELLS PURCHASED 220 ACRES of land
bordering the south side of the Red River
from William Crawford, an earlier settler. 9
On the property was a double-log, weather boarded
house with six large and comfortable rooms. The
house stood about 100 yards down a fenced lane,
which led to the Brown's Ford and Springfield Road.
It was one of the finest farms in the community at
the time, boasting a large pear orchard in the back
and several pear trees on the front lawn. The well
was about 100 yards north of the house, and the
family cemetery was located atop a cedar-covered hill
about 300 yards to the northwest. Several large
fields had been cleared before the Bells moved to the
area, beyond which were dense forests that
flourished with wild plants and berries, deer, rabbits
and other animals.
9 Robertson County, Tennessee, Deed Book E , p. 126.
THE BELL WITCH: THE FULL ACCOUNT
29
The Red River Community
Thought by many to be the prettiest stream in the
country, nearby Red River abounded with game fish
and carried the beautiful and melodic sounds of
swirls and ripples.