him . I didnât hear what he said from here.â
âYou heard him, Conk.â
âYes,â the doctor said. ââThe heroine.ââ
âThatâs what he said.â Ellery turned away. He felt as empty as Benedict looked.
âThe heroine.â Dullman laughed. âGet what you wanted, Queen? Feel like a big man now?â
âHe didnât know her name,â Ellery said, as if this explained something important. He was wiping his face over and over.
âI donât understand,â Dr. Farnham said.
âBenedict arrived so late tonight there wasnât time for introductions. He could only identify her by her role in the play. The heroine.â
Ellery turned away.
âBut I took Joanâs appendix out when she was fifteen,â Dr. Farnham muttered, as if that absolved her. âMy father delivered her,â as if that clinched it.
Someone rapped on the door. Dullman opened it.
âIâm told somethingâs happened to Mr. Benedictââ
âWell, look whoâs here,â Dullman said. âCome on in, Bluefield.â
ACT II. Scene 2.
Scutney Bluefieldâs shoes and the cuffs of his trousers were soaked.
âIâve been walking and walking. You see, I couldnât stand what he was doing to the play. I felt that if I stayed one minute longer â¦â
âScutney,â Ellery said.
âAnd how dreadful,â Scutney went on, still looking at the occupied chair. âI mean, he doesnât look human any more, does he? Iâve never seen this kind of death.â
âScutneyââ
âBut he brought it on himself, wouldnât you say? You canât go about humiliating people that way. People whoâve never done you any harm. Who killed him?â
Ellery swung the little man around. âYouâll have to talk to your audience, Scutney. I think youâd better use the word accident. And tell your ushers privately not to allow anyone to leave the theater until the police get here.â
âWho killed him?â
âWill you do that?â
âYes, of course,â Scutney said. He squished out, leaving a damp trail.
Ellery wandered back to the dressing table. All at once he stooped for a closer look at the knife handle.
Dr. Farnham stirred.
âItâs a fact theyâre taking their sweet time,â Dullman said. âYou want out, Doctor?â
âI left my wife in the audience,â Farnham said stiffly.
âDonât worry about Molly, Conk.â Ellery dug a small leather case out of his pocket. âAnd youâre my corroborating witness to Benedictâs statement.â
âThatâs right,â Dullman said. âI didnât hear a thing. I donât have the stomach that goes with ears like yours.â
The case produced a powerful little lens, and through it Ellery examined the handle of the knife on both sides.
âWhat,â Dullman jeered, âno deerstalker hat?â
Ellery ignored him. The heavy haft had been recently wound in black plastic friction tape. An eighth of an inch from the edge, the tape showed a straight line of thin, irregular indentations some five-eighths of an inch long. In a corresponding position on the underside there was a line of indentations similar in character and length.
Ellery stowed away his lens. âBy the way, Dullman, have you seen this knife before?â
âAny particular reason why I should tell you?â
âAny particular reason why you shouldnât?â
âItâs not mine. I donât know whose it is.â
âBut you have seen it before.â When Dullman did not answer, Ellery added, âBelieve me, I know how sincerely you wish you were out of this.â The way Dullmanâs glance shifted made Ellery smile faintly. âBut you canât wish away Benedictâs murder, and in any case youâll have to submit to police questioning. Where have