produced by the most carefully thought-out artifice.
âAnyway, what are people supposed to do, go into mourning?â Roger sounded as if he had been following a separate train of thought. âHe was a smutty old man. If ever anyone asked for it, he did.â
Ellery kept watching Joanâs reflection in the mirror. âYou know, Rodge, thatâs very much like a remark Scutney made a few minutes ago. It rather surprises me. Granted Benedictâs outrageous behavior tonight, it was hardly sufficient reason to stick a knife in his back. Wouldnât you say?â The lipstick in Joanâs fingers kept flying. âOrâon second thoughtâdoes either of you know of a sufficient reason? On the part of anyone?â
âHow could we know a thing like that?â
âSpeak for yourself, Rodge,â Ellery smiled. âHow about you, Joan?â
She murmured, âMe?â and shook her head at herself.
âWell.â Ellery pushed away from the door. âOh. Roger, last night in Arch Dullmanâs room, when Benedict was first mentioned as a substitute for Manson, I got the impression you knew Benedict from somewhere. Was I imagining things?â
âI canât help your impressions.â
âThen you never met him before tonight?â
âI knew his smelly reputation.â
âThatâs not what the lawyers call a responsive answer,â Ellery said coldly.
Roger glared. âAre you accusing me of Benedictâs murder?â
âAre you afraid I may have cause to?â
âYouâd better get out of here!â
âUnfortunately, you wonât be able to take that attitude with the police.â
âGet out!â
Ellery shrugged as part of his own act. He had baited Roger to catch Joan off guard. And he had caught her. She had continued her elaborate toilet at the mirror as if they were discussing the weather. His hostile exchange with Roger should have made her show some sign of alarm, or anxiety, or at least interest.
He left gloomily.
He was not prepared for the police officer he found in charge below, despite a forewarning of long standing. On the retirement of Wrightsvilleâs perennial chief of police, Dakin, the old Yankee had written Ellery about his successor.
âSelectmen brought in this Anselm Newby from Connhaven,â Dakin had written, âwhere he was a police captain with a mighty good record. Newbyâs young and heâs tough and far as I know heâs honest and he does know modern police methods. But heâs maybe not as smart as he thinks.
âIf you ever get to Wrightsville again, Ellery, better steer clear of him. Once told him about you and he gives me a codfish look and says no New York wiseacre is ever going to mix into his department. Itâs a fact there ainât much to like about Anse.â
Ellery had visualized Chief of Police Newby as a large man with muscles, a jaw, and a Marine sergeantâs voice. Instead, the man in the chiefâs cap who turned to look him over when he was admitted to the dressing room was short and slight, almost delicately built.
âI was just going to send a man looking for you, Mr. Queen.â Chief Newbyâs quiet voice was another surprise. âWhereâve you been?â
The quiet voice covered a sting; it was like the swish of a lazily brandished whip. But it was Newbyâs eyes that brought old Dakinâs characterization into focus. They were of an inorganic blue, unfeeling as mineral.
âTalking to members of the company.â
âLike Joan Truslow?â
Ellery thought very quickly. âJoan was one of them, Chief. I didnât mention Benedictâs talking before he died, of course. But as long as we had to wait for youââ
âMr. Queen,â Newby said. âLetâs understand each other right off. In Wrightsville a police investigation is run by one man. Me.â
âTo my knowledge
R. C. Farrington, Jason Farrington