heâd picked out himself. Actually heâd watched her on television, and heâd come of his own volition.
âHe has a sex problem,â the Counselorâs Wife said. âHe announced that right off the bat, the first session. Almost before he sat down. He said he could do sex in the sense of getting an erection, doing intercourse, but it didnât go anywhere for him. That was what he called it: doing sex, doing intercourse. He said he didnât get aroused, didnât feel anything particularly. Nothing happened. He didnât come. Finally the erection would just go away, either because he got tired or else bored.
âYou should know that itâs not uncommon at all, although Iâve never met a male patient who didnât think it was unique to him. Thereâs a whole body of case literature on the subject. But thatâs not the point. He wanted to deal with it, for me to deal with it, like ⦠like it was an abstraction. I mean, I was a sex therapist, wasnât I? Well, if all he wanted was to have pleasure in sex like anybody else, he didnât see why I was interested in what heâd dreamt as a child. The usual stuff.
âAnyway, it turned out not to be so simple. It never is, otherwise â¦â
She got the recorder going then.
To listen to all sheâd taped would have taken a lot longer than the time we had, but even the playbacks sheâd selected had a kind of mind-numbing effect. Maybe shrinks are used to it, maybe they can listen to a disembodied voice and fill in the blanks, but I didnât know what he looked like, couldnât see the body language that went with his flat, nasal, preppy-sounding accent, and I couldnât help focusing on his verbal tics, like the way he had of tacking âyou know?â on to the back of his sentences, turning every other sentence into a question. There were the pauses too, long ones sometimes, when you imagined him sitting in the chair I was sitting in or just lying on the couch and the Counselorâs Wife waiting, just waiting, and even though I knew that part of being a shrink is getting the patient to bounce words off the blank wall of the shrink, I didnât see how she could stand it.
To hear him tell it, he and his peers spent most of their nights hanging out in a bunch of East Side bars, waiting for the âbridge-and-tunnel bunniesâ to show up. They called it âtrolling.â The saloons were the kind that cater to the under-age crowd. The bunnies were girls from Brooklyn, Queens, the Island, out for high times and kicks and sometimes getting more than theyâd bargained for. The Counselorâs Wife may have called it group sex; to me it sounded like gang bangs, sometimes uglier than that, and the wonder of it was that this Carter McCloyâfor that turned out to be his nameâhadnât long since had the shit kicked out of him by vengeful bridge-and-tunnel fathers and brothers.
He hadnât. He claimed that he didnât take part in the rough stuff. Maybe so. But he also told about one of the schools heâd been expelled from years before. A faculty daughter had claimed that Carter McCloy had beaten her up. According to Carter McCloy, the faculty daughter had made him do it. The scandal had been hushed up; McCloy had been sent home.
If he hadnât taken part, then heâd certainly watched. He described it in detail, and it took me a while to realize that the detail was for the Counselorâs Wifeâs benefit. Because, to hear him tell it, he didnât feel a thing.
âWhy donât you ever say anything?â he said at one point, and you could hear the irritation in his otherwise flat voice. âI mean, youâre always asking me stuff like: âHow did you feel about that? Did that give you pleasure?ââ Pause. âThe great Dr. Saroff. Why donât you tell me what she feels?â
Pause.
âI wasnât there,â