was twenty-six when we met,â he said. Six words. This was the richest response heâd given me in the hour since Iâd started the evaluation.
For at least the fifth time since heâd come into the bare, windowless cubicle, Nick glanced furtively about. He twisted around and checked the wall and floor behind him. Then he
turned back. As he shifted in his seat, the chains from leg irons dragged on the floor.
Iâd started off, as I always did with someone I evaluated, by telling him that I was there to help the team prepare his defense. I was reminded, once again, of the unique relationship between forensic psychologist and prisoner. My time is limited and my goals quite specific: to find exculpatory evidence. Typically, defendants are highly motivated to give me what they think I want, which often has its own problems.
But Nick seemed oblivious to that script. Iâd begun with a mental status exam, hoping to ease his way into answering with the relatively innocuous questions. But even these encountered resistance. From the way he crossed his arms and avoided eye contact, to his terse responses, the message was clear: He didnât trust. I needed him to lower his defenses enough to get our conversation to flow before I took him back through the crime.
As Iâd expected, Nick knew exactly where he was and why. He didnât seem suicidal. He also admitted that he didnât feel safe. Under the circumstances, that could be considered normal. There were no frank hallucinations or delusions.
I began to probe his relationship with his wife. âYou had a happy marriage?â
âI loved my wife,â Nick said. He focused on the oatmeal-colored Formica tabletop. âWe had our occasional problems.â
âAnything in particular?â
âLike what?â
âYou said you were having problems.â
âYou know, problems. Everybody has problems.â
âSure. I know everyone has problems. How bad were yours?â It felt like pulling teeth.
âWe saw someone, couple of times,â he said, still evading the question.
âA marriage counselor?â I asked. Nick nodded. âWhat did you talk to her about?â
âNot her. Him.â Nick swallowed and stared off into space. âDo I have to talk about it? Why donât you ask him?â
âMay I? Iâd like very much to do that,â I said.
I wouldnât have been surprised if heâd balked when I took him up on the offer, but he didnât. He said, âDr. Richard Teitlebaum. Heâs in Newton.â The name sounded vaguely familiar. I wondered if this was the DR. T on their kitchen calendar.
I turned to a fresh sheet of paper and quickly wrote a paragraph that would release Dr. Teitlebaum to talk to me, and vice versa. I pivoted it and handed Nick the pen.
âWhatâs this?â
âHeâll need to see that youâve given him your permission to talk to me.â
He read what Iâd written, turned the page over and inspected the back. Then he gave me a guarded look and drew a diagonal line across the blank sideâensuring, I suppose, that I couldnât add anything. He turned it back over and signed.
âYou ever see anyone else to talk to?â I asked. âOn your own?â
âA shrink?â Nick shook his head. âI only went to Teitlebaum because it was important to Lisa.â
âAnd you tried to do the things that your wife wanted you to?â
Nick picked at a curling corner of the Formica top until a little piece broke off. âI loved my wife.â
The room had turned stuffy. I took off my jacket and hung it over the back of my chair. Nickâs glance fell to my belt. He leaped up, the chair crashing over behind him. âWhat the hell is that? Youâre taping this!â He was staring bug-eyed at the pager the guard had given me.
âWhoa, time-out,â I said, unhooking the gadget. âItâs a panic