needed sleep. I wondered how long it would be before the image of the young womanâs butchered body would wash out of my consciousness.
Chip walked us through the laundry room and to the door to the garage. A step farther and heâd have lost sight of Nick sitting at the kitchen table. Chip lowered his voice. He told me heâd talked to Detective Boley. âThey think the cause of death is related to a head trauma. Her skull is pretty well dented.â
âThe fireplace poker?â I whispered.
âProbably.â
Head trauma? If a blow to the head was what killed her, then why butcher her and then drown her? I could already imagine the newspaper headlines: Overkill. There would be interviews with so-called experts pontificating on the psychology of it. Theyâd probably tell the drooling reporter that overkill wasnât unusual in a âthrill killingâ where typically two or more killers gang up on a stranger just for the fun of it. More often you saw it in crimes of passion against a loved one. Then, the violence was intimateâstrangling and stabbing as opposed to shooting or poisoningâand the perpetrator was often a man driven by a terror of being abandoned.
Chip held his hand over his mouth. âAnd they found bloody clothing in the bathroom hamper. Nickâs. Looks like he changed his clothes and took a shower before he drove his mother to Oakvale.â
I turned my back to the kitchen and said quietly, âIf he didnât
kill his wife, then how the hell did Nick get blood all over his clothing?â
âI have no idea.â Chipâs voice was weary. âIâm hoping heâll be able to explain.â Chip glanced back at Nick. He was sitting at the table, watching us from under the cap brim. He looked quickly away, got up, and opened the refrigerator.
âWeird,â Annie whispered. âI wonder why he didnât change his shoes.â
âShoes?â Chip asked.
Nick took a glass out of the cabinet and ran the water at the sink.
âLooks like theyâre spattered with blood,â I said. âWouldnât you think someone changing his clothes to cover up his involvement in a murder would change his shoes too?â
âNot much of a cover-up if he leaves his bloody shirt hanging halfway out of the laundry basket in the bathroom,â Chip added.
Chip went on to say that he expected Nick to be arrested. Heâd request bail, of course, but said heâd be surprised if the judge granted it. âThe DA is going to want to get the stateâs shrink in to interview him,â Chip said. âIâve already told Nick not to talk to anybody unless I say so. I hope youâll have time to get in there and evaluate him right away.â
âWhoa, hold your horses,â I said. It came out louder than Iâd intended. I was glad that Nick had the water running as he rinsed out the glass.
Were there some crimes so horrific that they rendered the standard arguments for mitigating circumstancesâinsanity, diminished capacityâirrelevant? And when had we slipped from being concerned friends and friends of a friend to being Nickâs attorney and support team? There were plenty of things I could see doing with my time other than defending a man whoâd butchered his wife.
âIâm not so sure youâre going to want my help on this case.
Thereâre lots of other folks out there who, for the right amount, will do whatever you want them to do and testify accordingly.â
Chip did a double take. His eyes widened. âPeter â¦â he started.
I realized that hadnât come out the way Iâd intended. âIâm sorry. That sounded like I was questioning your ethics, and I donât. But you canât just assume that Iâm going to jump in and help. And Iâm not so sure youâre going to want my help on this case. Iâve got very strong biases about men who kill
Morten Storm, Paul Cruickshank, Tim Lister