this thing started, we must have been through it a thousand times. Youâve made your point, youâve argued your case. Your last chance was Dublin. You said so yourself, you said it was the last ditch. For goodness sake, even your own mother says you should give it up.â
âDonât you dare use my mother against me!â Her voice was sharp with anger. âWhatâs happened to you? Youâre supposed to be an artist, arenât you? A thinking man? Can you not see that itâs against nature itself to cut the top off a mountain, any mountain, no matter where, just for a pot of stinking gold. All gold is foolâs gold, donât you know that? You cut the top off the Big Hill, you dig out whateverâs inside, and you suck out the soul of this place. Thereâll be nothing left. Whatâll it take to make you see it, Jimmy?â She cried then and Jessie could see in her mindâs eye her father putting his arms round her and shushing her against his shoulder. âI canât let them do it, Jimmy,â she wept. âI wonât.â
âI know, I know. But whatever happens, Cath, donât go hating me for what I think. Iâve been honest with you. I must be honest and say what I think, you know that. Weâve a whole life to lead here, Jess to look after, wood to sculpt and hundreds of silly sheep with their limping feet and their dirty little tails. We mustnât have this thing between us.â After that there was a lot of sniffling, and then subdued laughter.
âAnd talking of honesty, Jimmy Parsons.â It was her mother again, happier now, âJess tried the Big Hill again, didnât she? Thatâs how she hurt herself, isnât it?â
âYou canât stop her, Cath. And whatâs more I donât think we should. All right, so she fell over and hurt herself, but at least she tried. And if thatâs anyoneâs fault, itâs yours. You were forever telling her, remember? âYou can do it,â youâd say. âYou can do anything you want, if you want it badly enough. Forget about your lousy palsy.â Well, thatâs just what sheâs doing. Sheâs set her heart on reaching the top of the Big Hill. Sheâs a brave little heart and Iâm not about to stop her from trying.â
âHow far did she get?â
âTo the top, of course. Doesnât she always? You know Jessie and her capacity for wishful thinking, for telling stories. But I think maybe she got a lot further up this time. She was so happy, so pleased with herself. Wouldnât it be just about the best thing in the world if she really made it, if one day she really made it right to the top of the Big Hill?â
âThere you are then, Jimmy,â said her mother, so softly Jessie could scarcely hear, âanother reason if you ever needed one, and maybe the best reason, why the Big Hill has to be saved. Call it holy, call it magic, call it what you will, but there is something about that mountain, Jimmy. I canât describe it. Iâve been up there hundreds of times in my life and you know something? Iâve never once felt alone.â
Listening in her bed, turning her gold earring over and over in her hand, the indisputable evidence that she had indeed reached the summit of the Big Hill that afternoon, Jessie was tempted to go downstairs, burst into the kitchen and tell them the whole story from beginning to end: the climb, the voice, the earring, everything. She was boiling with indignation at her parentsâ disbelief, at their lack of faith. Yet she knew there was no point in protesting. She had been caught out often enough before, and by both of them too. She was a good storyteller, but a bad liar because she always went too far, became too fantastical.
Yes, she could dangle the earring in their faces, but what of the rest of the story? Why should they believe her just because sheâd found an earring?