spouse the automatic best suspect?â
âGenerally, yes. But Plummer had a dinner meeting that night, and a whole crowd of young gearhead entrepreneurs and their lawyers has given him an alibi until nearly 1 in the morning. Coroner says the time of death was between 11 p.m. and midnight.â
âOkay. But, going back to Gifford, why would he leave a dead body in his car, in his garage?â
Isabella shrugged. âThe prosecution had an answer for that, too. The limousine had darkened windows, no one could see in. He didnât know anyone would open the doorâthey claimed he planned to get rid of the body later that day.â
âAnd what about the gun? You said Travis was licensed to carry one. Did they find the gun used to shoot Mrs. Plummer? Was it Travisâs gun?â
âThey did find it,â said Isabella, âand it wasnât his. Different caliber. It was wrapped in a pretty disgusting mess of used kitty litter in a trash can next door to Travisâs apartment building. It was impossible to tell whose gun it was, because the serial numbers had been obliterated.â
âWhat does your client think really happened?â
âHe doesnât know. He figuresâwe all figureâthat if she had something going with him, she might have had other extracurricular activities. Though he admits he didnât think shedid. And it didnât much matter, because we couldnât turn anything up before the trial.â
âAnd now?â
âWell, during the habeas process, weâve got an investigator looking into everything. But frankly, people like the Plummers donât have lives that open themselves easily to the kinds of investigators we can hire.â
Eleanor cleared her throat. âWhich is where you come in, Maggie.â
I looked at her. She had that carefully neutral expression I was used to seeing on the faces of my children when I was trying to ascertain who had fed the dog underneath the dinner table.
âThe Plummers and their friends are exactly the kinds of people Small Town covers. Youâve got access to a world and information we just donât have.â
Moments like this were precisely when I realized I should have gone to journalism school instead of, as a literature and piano student, lying around on rump-sprung sofas, reading 18th-century novels or scouring the music building for hunky cellists to play chamber music with. I should know how to respond, but I didnât have a clue.
I shook my head. âI donât know. This doesnât smell all that different to me than the cops coercing information out of media organizations.â I held up my hand. âI know, your cause is just and all that. But, if you do it for one side, you do it for the other.â
âWait a second,â said Isabella. âWeâre not asking you to turn over confidential interviews.â
âWhat are you asking, exactly?â I said, as I put the file back on Isabellaâs lap.
Isabella put the file on the floor between us.
âJust this. I think thereâs more to the story that we could understand if we had access to the Plummersâ lives. How does a woman like Grace Plummer spend her time? Who does she hang out with when she is doing all her socialite charity activities? Whoâs her hairdresser? What valet parkers does she hire if sheâs having aparty?â She unfolded her legs, stood up, and started wandering around the living room, patting her pockets in the unmistakable tic of a recently reformed smoker.
âLook, Maggie. Itâs not all that different from the journalism professor at Northwestern who sent his class out to uncover evidence to have that Death Row case reopened.â
âIt is different,â I said. âThose kids werenât working journalists, with a responsibility to a publisher and to their readers. Plus, Iâm not an investigative reporter. Iâm an editor. I sit in