Elias wasnât sure how to talk with a man who couldnât talk back.
âI donât mean to trouble you, sir,â Elias went on. âBut if you could spare some feed for that pigeon you give me, or at least tell me what he eats, Iâdââ
The curtain whipped open.
Pennyrile stood there, not quite smiling, but not looking entirely displeased to find Elias at his door. In his hands he held a slate and a nub of chalk. He was bundled up in a long wool coat, the collar revealing a new wrap at his neck, this one finished off with the same elaborate knot as before. But as he moved, the fabric shifted, revealing a lumpy edge of bluish purple, like an old bruise, glinting beneath a layer of ointment. Bear fat and whale oil, Elias recalled the doctor saying, the odor suddenly recognizable to him. Whale oil they burned at home, and on board his fatherâs ships. Elias forced himself to look the man in the eye. Despite his size, Elias could see that Pennyrile was indeed losing weight like the doctor said. His face, deeply lined and spotted all over by the sun, had begun to hollow out, the cheeks caving in.
âI . . . good morning, um . . .â Elias had almost forgotten the reason for his errand.
And then he heard a sound that made him remember a different life. One where heâd have been right then if he werenât so sick. Pennyrile began writing across the slate. It was just like the one Elias had used in school back in Norfolk, the same kind Horace Peters had cracked over Merriman Oakesâs head when Merriman had called Horace a Yankee. Pennyrile wrote quickly, the chalk scratching and shrieking. After a second he turned the slate around and tapped the words heâd written there.
Victor Pennyrile. The printing was spindly, all lowercase letters.
He tapped his chest.
âI know,â Elias said. âIâm Elias. Elias Harrigan. Pleased to meet you.â
Pennyrile pointed at his neck, at the kerchief he had knotted there.
âDoc Croghan told me. Iâm sorry for you.â
Pennyrile shrugged, like it couldnât be helped. Then he pointed at Eliasâs chest, almost touching it. Elias flinched, but he understood the question in the gesture.
âYes, sir,â he said. âMy lungsâre bad.â
Pennyrile kept his black eyes fixed on Elias as he scratched something more onto the slate, the rasp of the chalk more whisper than screech this time.
So young, the slate said when he held it out, and he looked at Elias like he was a horse that needed putting down.
Elias bristled, suddenly recalling how quickly Pennyrileâd been ready to snap Bedivereâs neck. âI donât want to keep you, but could you maybe spare some feed?â
Pennyrile motioned Elias to follow him inside.
It was much the same as Eliasâs hut, with its narrow bed and table and stove and shelves. But pushed up against one wall was a great tin washtub. Elias shuddered, glad no one had brought up the notion of a proper bath yet. He searched for some other place to put his eyes. Right inside the door, half filling the window, was a set of wooden cages.
The pigeon loft.
Elias didnât know much about keeping birds, but a quick glance told him that the enclosure had been built for more birds than the two it held now. They seemed almost lonesome in there.
âWhyâs it so empty?â
Pennyrile wrote again. Had lots more. Sent them out already.
âYou gonna have whoeverâs been getting the messages send âem back?â
Pennyrile swiped the slate clean with a scrap of red cloth and wrote again. Too much bother. He paused, then wrote more. Didnât figure on being here this long.
âYou can always send out messages with the regular post, canât you?â
Pennyrile shook his head, acted as if he would not elaborate, but then wrote: This way better.
Elias wasnât sure how he figured that, what with the birds getting