Holly," Joel added with completely sincerity.
"All we've ever wanted is for you to admit the feelings were mutual," Alan finished.
"We talked about it," Colin continued. "About the hypothetical situation of one of us getting to date you. It almost came to fisticuffs. Then we realized that was exactly what you wanted to avoid."
"I - I still don't get it. That's way too mature for teenagers," I replied.
"It takes a truly special girl," Alan took his place, "to make you realize you have the one in front of you. You forgot that these two buffoons are my best friends too, and we've gotten along for more than a decade. Why were we going to abandon that when a solution was obvious?"
"We can share, Holly," Joel said, stepping forward and taking my hand.
"Share...?"
"We don't want to risk losing you. If we fought each other, it may drive you away. We admitted to ourselves the only way to have you was to share. We all claim your body as our own, we all remain best friends. The only thing that changes is that these parties? Well, they're about to get a lot more interesting."
"The three of you? All of you, just for me?" I was still lost in awe.
"You're that fucking special, Holly," Colin said, leaning in, whispering in my ear. "Now lose those panties. Those were the rules we agreed to after all."
My heart started beating hard. I never realized this was possible. That they had the maturity to handle something like this.
If they loved me, I loved them, and there was going to be no conflict, I wanted to share everything with them.
Including my body. I stood up, and pushed the panties down, baring my naked form completely to them.
Joel chuckled looking me over. "Smart, best damn Mario Kart player ever, sweet, all that and sexy as hell too. Yeah, you're the kind of girl who deserves three men like us."
Joel, already stripped to the waist, leaned down on me, letting his hand caress down my back. My flesh started to come to life underneath his touch, and it slowly dawned on me that I really was getting what I always wanted. His hands curved around my soft ass, getting a good grip on there, letting him appreciate me in my complete nudity.
"Goddamn, Holly. It's not fair you kept this body from us all this time," he said, as he started to kiss down my body. Past my neck, over my chest, across my abdomen, and came to what I had been so afraid to share. A single finger was pushed in, "Wet as fuck too. You've been thinking about this for awhile, haven't you?"
I nodded enthusiastically. "Every night, I'd think about one of you as I touched myself."
"What a coincidence," Alan added as he came at my body from another angle, running his fingers around my nipples, making them spike up good and hard. "Every night since I stopped thinking you had cuties I've masturbated thinking about you, Holly. Your body, these breasts, so perfect."
He leaned down and sucked on one, the tingling sensation washing over my body with each suckle and intensity.
"Don't we all?" Colin made his way to the other side of the bed. "I mean, always so close to one another. This had to be the inevitable thing, didn't it?"
With my breasts and pussy occupied, Colin went a more sensual route. He stroked my hair, lifting my head, bringing it closer to his lips. "You can't believe what a tease that stage kiss was. Just being that close to you, it was the most exciting moment of my life."
He followed it with another kiss on my lips. Maybe it was because of his love of the theater, but I was quickly coming to realize Colin was the best kisser, and he knew it.
That wasn't to say the others didn't have their uses. Joel kept pushing his finger in deeper to my pussy, running into something that halted his advance. "Holly - you're a virgin?"
Colin broke away to let me answer. I nodded. "I couldn't be with another guy without thinking about you three. You've ruined me for the rest of the world."
Joel shook his head. "Here I am, thinking that if I slept with another girl,