told the judge,â Matt surmised.
âThere were two possibilities,â I explained. âEither my client was a very stupid man who was taken advantage of by an unscrupulous seller, or heââ
âOr he was a very stupid man who stole a car and didnât have the brains to fill out a bogus bill of sale with a believable sellerâs name,â Riordan finished. âI take it you didnât see fit to present the judge with that alternative.â
âI told the judge my client was a cane-cutting peasant from Puerto Rico who got ripped off by a city slicker named Bobo,â I admitted.
âWhat happened to the case?â
âGod, I donât remember. This happened years ago.â
âBut you tried to get your guy a better deal on the basis of a bill of sale you had some reason to believe he might have forged. That might be penny ante stuff compared to Nunzieâs trip to Barbados, but the principle is the same. Does a good defense attorney look a gift horse in the mouth?â
âHe does if the horse might turn around and bite him.â
He considered that remark in silence; this horse had bitten Matt with a vengeance. But I did erase one of the two check marks Iâd placed in my mental Hell, no column.
âAnd then?â I prompted, bringing him back to the matter at hand.
âAnd then Lazarus, the snake, put the squeeze on Nunzie,â he said. âHe promised him a walk if heâd incriminate me in the phony alibi. Word on the street is that Nunzie bought the deal and told Lazarus that he was given the documents by my investigator.â
âThis is Fat Jack Vance, the bail bondsman?â He was a legend in Manhattan court circles; the fat man and Riordan went back a long way together.
Matt nodded. âThe next word I hear is that Lazarus sent Nunzie into the grand jury to get an indictment for subornation of perjury against Jack and me.â
âAnd right after that, Nunzie Aiello went missing,â I finished. Nunzieâs disappearance right after his grand jury appearance had been the subject of a certain amount of press speculation. Half the reporters in town thought heâd taken a strategic trip to the Old Country, while the other half had him swimming in the East River in cement shoes. Either way, his absence was Riordanâs reprieve. There could be no trial without the chief witness.
âLazarus was steamed, I take it.â
âLazarus was rabid,â Riordan amended. âNow there was even wild talk he was going to prove I killed Nunzie to prevent him from testifying against me.â
I finished the story for him. âAnd then, last October, the Department of Sanitation towed a derelict car from under the Williamsburg Bridge. The car was in the pound for a month. It was about to be auctioned, when the guys inspecting it smelled something rotten. They opened the trunk, and there was Nunzie. One bullet to the head, another in the mouth.â
âClassic,â was all Matt said. âThe bullet in the mouth is a traditional way of marking an informer.â
âDo you think Cretella did it?â I asked. This was, strictly speaking, irrelevant to Mattâs defense. But I had decided that if the answer was yes, Matt would have to keep looking for counsel. I could represent Matt himself without becoming known as a Mafia lawyer, but if there were deeper Mob crimes underlying Mattâs troubles, I preferred to stay on the Brooklyn side of the bridge.
Mattâs eyes narrowed; at first, I thought he resented the question. But his thoughtful tone told me that he was thinking the matter through. âIf Nunzie was shtupping me,â he said in an uncharacteristically tentative tone, âthen he was probably sticking it to Frankie too. Iâve represented Frank Cretella for almost fifteen years now, and this isnât the first of his former associates to be found with a bullet in his mouth.â
âYou
Dick Bass, Frank Wells, Rick Ridgeway