protect us all.â
But Rebels often frustrate others because they canât be asked or told to do anything. They donât care if âpeople are counting on you,â âyou said youâd do it,â âyour parents will be upset,â âitâs against the rules,â âthis is the deadline,â or âitâs rude.â In fact, asking or telling Rebels to do something often makes them do just the opposite . A Rebel wrote: âBeing told or expected to do something creates a âstopâ sensation that I have to actively overcome. If Iâm asked to empty the dishwasher, my brain says, âWell, I was going to, but now you went and asked, so I canât. So no.â â
The people around Rebels must guard against accidentally igniting their spirit of oppositionâparticularly challenging for the parents of Rebel children. One parent explained, âThe best way to wrangle the Rebel child is to give the kid the information to make a decision, present the issue as a question that he alone can answer, and let him make a decision and act without telling you. Let him make a decision without an audience. Audiences = expectations. If he thinks youâre not watching, he wonât need to rebel against your expectations.â Another parent: âMy Rebel son got expelled and didnât want to work toward a career, though heâs very smart. When he turned eighteen, we gave him an around-the-world plane ticket and said, âOver to you!â He traveled for three years, and now heâs in grad school, and doing very well.â
Rebels sometimes frustrate even themselves, because they canât tell themselves what to do. Writer John Gardner observed, âMy compulsion not to do what people tell me ⦠makes me change places of living or change my life in one way or another, which often make me very unhappy. I wish I could just settle down.â On the other hand, Rebels can be skillful at channeling their Rebel energy in constructive ways. A Rebel who wants to stick to a budget might say, âI wonât be manipulated by marketers trying to sell me junk,â or a Rebel who wants to succeed in school might say, âNo one thinks I can get into a good college, but Iâll show them.â
Rebels often gravitate toward work with a Wild West elementâsuch as my Rebel friend who works in disruptive technology (not just any technology, heâs careful to emphasize, but disruptive technology). Rebels resist hierarchies and rules, and they often work better with others when theyâre in charge. However, the opposite of a profound truth is also true, and surprisingly, some Rebels gravitate to institutions with many rules. As one commenter noted, âLetting others have control can bring freedom as well. Youâd probably find more Rebels in the military than youâd suspect.â Another Rebel noted: âPerhaps Rebels need a boundary to bend, flex, and break. Left to my own devices, I become restless and unproductive because there are no rules to break or no to-do list, which at the end of the day I look at, and think, âHooray, I didnât do any of those things.â â
Anytime I speak about the Tendencies, I ask people to raise their hands to indicate their category. I was surprised when a group of Christian ministers had an unusually high percentage of Rebels. A Rebel clergy member explained: âClergy think of themselves as called and therefore different. They have the blessing of their colleagues, congregation, and God, which sets them above many things in life, including rules.â
No surpriseâRebels resist habits. I met a woman who was, I immediately realized, a Rebel. I asked, âDonât you find it exhausting to make choices every single day?â
âNo,â she answered. âMaking choices makes me feel free.â
âI give myself limits to give myself freedom,â I