took it, sat down, and wrote:
Who is the first boy that Sophie Chafik is going to kiss?
âWhat did it say?â Sophie was practically climbing onto the desk.
âNothing.â
âHuh. Do you think it only works if the question is about you?â
Ava looked at the pencil. âI donât think so. It told me how many fingers you were hiding.â
âWell that stinks!â Sophie crossed her arms, then got a worried look on her face. âAsk it something else, okay? Make sure itâs not broken.â
âLike what?â
âSomething easy. Like a math formula.â
âMath formulas are
not
easy.â But Ava wrote:
What is the formula for the circumference of a circle?
The voice said, âTwo pi R,â just as loud and clear as ever.
âIt still works,â Ava said.
âWell, why wouldnât it tell you who Iâm going to kiss?â Sophie glared at the pencil. âAsk it why it wonât answer my question.â
âIt probably wonât answer that either.â But Ava wrote:
Why wouldnât you answer the question about the first boy Sophie is going to kiss?
âBecause
that
is not a
fact
,â the voice said. It sounded cranky. âPeople have free will.â
Ava carefully put the pencil down. She was a little worried that it was getting tired and maybe mad at them. And who knew what an angry pencil-genie might do?
âDid it answer?â Sophie moved Ruffles the Owl aside and flopped down on Avaâs tie-dyed blue-and-green bedspread.
âYeah. It said who youâre going to kiss first isnât a fact, and that people have free will.â
âOh. That must be one of its rules.â Sophie sat with her mouthscrunched up for a few seconds and then nodded. âI guess that makes sense. But it would have been cool if it told future stuff. We could have gotten lottery numbers for next week.â
That felt like cheating to Ava, too, but she didnât say so.
âHey!â Sophie bounced up from the bed. âThat means it might still work for me. Can I try again?â
âGo ahead.â Ava traded places with Sophie. Then she remembered the pencilâs grumpy tone. âBe careful, though. I think itâs getting tired of us.â
âIf itâs a genie, itâs not allowed to get tired of us.â Sophie picked up the pencil, then gasped and put it down. âBut wait ⦠what if it
is
a genie and itâll only do a certain number of questions, like three wishes or something?â
Ava thought about that. âItâs okay. You can try it.â Even if there werenât many questions left, sheâd want Sophie to have a turn. âWhat are you going to ask?â
Sophie frowned for a second, then laughed out loud and reached for the pencil. âIâm going to ask it what color underwear Mr. Farkley was wearing today!â
âSophie, no! That is the grossest question ever!â
But Sophie was already scribbling. She finished and then doubled over in the chair laughing.
Ava really didnât want to know, but Sophie was laughing so hard she had to ask. âOkay, what? What did it say?â
Sophie held up a finger and tried to catch her breath. âGreen ⦠with ⦠with â¦â She started laughing again. âYellow smiley faces!â
Ava laughed, too. She couldnât imagine how she was ever going to take a math test with a straight face again. How could someone so strict choose smiley face underwear?
âAva, you girls okay in there?â a voice called from the hall.
âWeâre fine, Mom.â Instinctively, Ava tugged open her desk drawer and brushed the pencil inside as her mom came in, balancing a cup of tea and a pile of folders, legal pads, and
Money
magazines in her arms.
âWhatâs so funny?â
âJust the usual girl stuff,â Sophie said, still giggling.
Mom glanced at the schoolbooks on Avaâs