butâ¦â
Iâm fine , I want to say. But I canât make the lie come out of my mouth. Not to Alex. Heâs had a front-row seat to all my hurts and heartaches over the last fifteen years. He can tell when Iâm lying.
I pick up the photo album and flip a couple pages. âThis is what I looked like the last time she saw me.â
Alex glances down at the picture. Itâs me as a toddler wearing a pair of jeans and a fuzzy orange sweater with a pumpkin on it. My brown curls are pulled into tiny pigtails, and I sit in Mamaâs lap while she reads me The Poky Little Puppy . In the picture, sheâs smiling down at me. A month later she was gone.
âYou were real cute.â Alex pokes me. âStill are.â I donât smile, and he puts a hand on my arm. âScrew her, Ivy.â
âI know.â Claireâs been texting me the same thing since she found out, except she doesnât say âscrew.â You donât owe that woman a fucking thing. She left you. Forgiveness isnât really in Claireâs skill set. Since her dad walked out on her mom, Claire has refused to see him. He bought her a car when she turned eighteen, and she sent it back to the dealership. Abby, on the other hand, is the optimist. The peacemaker. Try to keep an open mind. Maybe sheâll surprise you.
I throw myself backward, stretching out on the rumpled blue quilt. Itâs easier to talk about my feelings without Alex looking at me. âI want her to hug me and say how sorry she is for leaving. That it wasnât my fault. But if she were that kind of person, that kind of mothe r ââ
âShe wouldnât have left in the first place.â
âYep.â I sit up again and close the album with a crack. âIâm so mad at her. For leaving. For never once getting in touch. But what am I supposed to do? I canât change what happened. Iâve just got to suck it up and make the best of things.â
âDo you? Seems to me sheâs the one ought to be walking on eggshells to make things easier on you, not the other way around.â
âFrom what Granddad says, sheâs not the type to walk on eggshells. More like smash them.â I let out a frustrated sigh. âItâs so pathetic! I just want her to like me! Since when I do care so much about what people think?â
Alex runs a hand through his dark curls and laughs. âSince always?â He shakes his head. âSheâs not some random person. Sheâs your mom. Of course you want her to like you. I just think you need to, like, manage your expectations.â
âSo I shouldnât have booked that mother-daughter spa day?â I raise my eyebrows. âTrust me, my expectations are set low. Way low. I mean, she never even sent me a birthday card.â My voice drops to a whisper, and I cover my face with my hand. âWhat did I do to make her hate me so much?â
Alex yanks on my elbow, hauling my hand away from my face. Traitorous tears are gathering in my eyes. âYou didnât do anything. You were just a baby. Whatever her deal is, itâs with the Professor, not you. You know how he can be.â
I pull away. I do know how he can be. The weight of his expectations is heavy, but that is no excuse for running out on your family. âDonât you make excuses for her. Granddadâheâs a good person. A good father.â
Alex puts his hands up. âHey, you donât have to convince me. Heâs the closest thing Iâve ever had to a dad.â
Alexâs father died in a car accident a few weeks before Erica left town. Marco and Luisa had just moved from Texas. Marco had gotten a job as an associate professor of math at the college. Once he got tenure and Alex got old enough for preschool, Luisa was going to open up her own bakery. Instead, her husband died, she became our housekeeper, and she and Alex moved into the carriage house.