one. She didnât want Roberta to worry the way she had last Halloween when she and Brenda had stayed out trick-or-treating until well past dark, even though they were supposed to be home before. But at the very last minute theyâd heard about a âreally good houseâ on the other side of town rumored to be handing out silver dollars as if they were M&Mâs, and theyâd been unable to resist.
As it turned out, that âreally good houseâ had been handing out chocolate coins, which were tasty but not worth getting into trouble for, which is exactly what Phoebe and Brenda got in. Roberta hid the very candy Phoebe had worked so hard to obtain. Brenda wasnât allowed to watch TV for a weekâa major blow considering the Cuddihy kids, despite their religious background, usually had unrestricted access to network television, whereas Phoebe and Emily were limited to one hour per day. (They could see all the public-television programming they wantedâas if they wanted it. At least, Phoebe didnât.)
Indeed, it was only under duress that she subjected herself to those British period dramas that made Leonard hallucinate with pleasure. The
Masterpiece Theatre
theme music was catchy, sure. As for the plotsâall those pasty English people getting worked up about who got to sit where in the baroucheâPhoebe was less than riveted. Her favorite evening drama was
The Dukes of Hazzard.
There were guaranteed to be at least two good car chases per episode. And the Duke brothersâunlike Emilyâalways treated their kid sister, Daisy, with the utmost respect. The only problem was that the show ran a full hour. So watching it meant forgoing her otherwise daily
Brady Bunch
and
I Love Lucy
rerun fix. Thatâs where Brenda came in. Phoebe could always count on her best friend for detailed plot descriptions of the previous nightâs shows.
When that got boring, theyâd talk about religion. Tears brimming in her lugubrious brown eyes, Brenda would implore Phoebeâherself of the gray-blue-eyed persuasionâto convert from her heretic faith. âHow can I walk to school with you every morning knowing youâre going straight to hell?â was Brendaâs preferred line of reasoning.
âBut I told you, we celebrate Christmas!â Phoebe would seek to reassure her. âAnd I swear Iâve only been to synagogue once in my entire life!â
Never to any avail.
BUT THAT FRIDAY night, as Phoebe and Brenda made their way âuptown,â they hardly spoke at all, such was their abject fear of their immediate surroundings. No matter that they knew every shrub along the way by heartâevery mailbox, streetlight, telephone pole, and patch of grass with four-leaf clover potential, too. In fact, they walked the same six blocks to and from Whitehead Middle every weekday morning and afternoon of their school-year lives. At the advanced hour of 7:30 P.M., however, so very foreboding seemed the landmarks of their school route that they might as well have been negotiating the slums of Rio de Janeiro. The rosebushes seemed eager to prick their fingers, the telephone poles intent on crushing their skulls. There was no doubt in either girlâs mind that famed serial murderer Son of Sam, though reported to be incarcerated, was lying in wait inside the bright blue mailbox on the corner of Catalpa and Main.
The little stone house on the corner of Briarcliff was another kind of horror storyâthe real kind. A year earlier, a veteran of the Vietnam War had sweet-talked his way into the basement, where heâd strangled to death a Whitehead ninth-grader in her own rec room. Brenda and Phoebe had stumbled upon the crime scene on their way to fourth grade. It had rained the night before. There were felled branches all over the street, and colored leaves blowing everywhere, and two Whitehead cop cars parked at right angles on the front lawn. And standing behind the yellow