added.â He tapped the glass again, lower down. âTitle, artistâs name, engraverâs name, date, anything.â
Miss Paxton listened in silence.
âProof before letter,â continued Gamadge, âis more valuable than lettered proof. Itâs scarcer, for one thing, and itâs often a finer impression. The engraver sometimes draws it himself. Now of course values differ very much from time to time in the case of things like this; fashions change, hobbies wax and wane, money is tight or free. Hall could only guess at these particular valuesââ
âThatâs why you asked him about the picture!â
âThatâs why. He guesses roughly that this impression we have before us now might be worth twenty-five to thirty dollars in the open market; but that a collector might pay a hundred for a proof before letter.â
âSeventy dollars difference?â
âIf you could find your market. In any case thereâd be some difference, I should say fifty dollars at least. But Miss Vance, or anybody, would have to be prepared with the less valuable picture in order to make the change, and sheâd have to be prepared with something elseâinformation.â
âYou mean she knew she could make the change without being interfered with?â
âCertainly that.â Gamadge stood contemplating Lady Audley biting the side of his thumb. He looked at Miss Paxton sideways. âYou know these are not common.â
âLady Audleys?â
âI never saw her before in my life. Rather a coincidence for Miss Vance, for anybody who knew that there was one already in the house, to own or pick up another one. Most of them must be in the books, you knowâthe books they were engraved for. All the lettered ones would be in the books unless somebody tore one out. Do you know what I think, Miss Paxton?â
âI canât even imagine, Henry.â
âI think this one must have been in the house too.â
âBoth of them in the house? I never heard that this one was.â
âWell, it may have been, and your cousin Lawson Ashbury may never have heard of it either. Itâs an inferior copy of the portrait your uncle was interested in; letâs say he acquired it first, and kept it in one of those tip-out receptacles in the book closet. Mr. Lawson Ashburyâdid he live here all his life?â
âNo, certainly not. He lived with Marietta in an apartment, or in the country.â
âNo reason why his father should keep him posted on all such purchases, was there?â
âNone at all.â
âWell, your uncle had this copy, and later on he found the finer one, the proof before letter. It was so fine and so much of an acquisition that he framed it and hung it in the hall. Heâd lost interest in this one, never spoke of it to you or the rest of the family.â
Miss Paxton said: âI canât for the life of me see why people shouldnât prefer the ones that have all the information on them.â
âAnd youâd probably rather have a set of books in a handsome binding than in the original boards, uncut and unopened. Collectors wouldnât, no matter how fine the binding. And if you cut a page in one of their dratted Firsts, so as to read what the author said, theyâd murder you.
âWell, we have the motiveâmalice, or a problematical seventy dollars. If we wanted to delve into psychology we might ask ourselves whether or not the very fact that the portrait resembled Mrs. Vincent Ashburyââ
âHenry, donât. Itâs too ugly.â
âI told you you wouldnât see the beauty of the case. Now for opportunity. Miss Vance, as we have already seen, may have had opportunity to change the pictures after she supposedly left on Sunday afternoon. We presume that she understood the difference in value between letter proof and proof before letter. Canât we presume that when she was
Serenity King, Pepper Pace, Aliyah Burke, Erosa Knowles, Latrivia Nelson, Tianna Laveen, Bridget Midway, Yvette Hines