Amanda to sit in on the sessions, even if she didnât say anything right away.
âWhy today?â Dr. Ben asked Amanda.
She offered a lazy teenager shrug. âMy mom needs me,â said Amanda. âSheâs been so strong. But I think itâs getting to her.â
âWhy do you say that?â
Amanda told him that Eloise had started sleepwalking, that she had found her mother on the living room floor this afternoon.
âIs that true?â asked Dr. Ben.
Now it was Eloiseâs turn to shrug. She really didnât want to get into this. âI suppose I had some kind of dream today.â She did not say that there was a girl sitting in her living room. And that it didnât seem like a dream at all. That she had this gnawing sense that there was something she was supposed to do but had no idea what. She wasnât going to say any of that.
âItâs not the first time,â said Amanda.
âIsnât it?â said Eloise, surprised.
âShe walks around at night, talking to people who arenât there.â
Eloise shook her head at the doctor to indicate that this was news to her.
âNo awareness of this, Eloise?â he asked. He pushed his glasses back, wore a concerned frown.
âNone,â she said.
He jotted down some notes. He didnât seem especially concerned with the content of her dreams, just that she was dreaming and moving about.
âSleepwalking can be a side effect of the medication youâre taking.â
She had been prescribed Ambien, but sheâd never taken it. She told him as much.
âWell, dreams and nightmares are to be expected in cases like this. Itâs your psycheâs way of working through the trauma youâve experienced.â
She wanted to argue that what sheâd experienced wasnât precisely a dream. But she wasnât going to open that can of worms, so she just nodded solemnly and said she understood. Which she did, because it seemed like Psychology 101. She promised that sheâd bring it up again next session if the sleepwalking continued.
â¢Â    â¢Â    â¢
Eloise and Amanda had taken to watching dinner with the television on, something not allowed before . But the nighttime was the hardest, just after the sun set, when they would usually have all been home togetherâthe girls doing their homework, Alfie grading papers, Eloise cooking dinner. It was always her favorite time of the day. Now she dreaded it.
But on Friday night, Amanda talkedâshe talked and talked. And Eloise listened as if her daughterâs voice were a song she loved but hadnât heard in too long. Amanda talked about what she remembered about that day, how sheâd been so mad at Emily who called her Marion the Librarian, and how she was always so mad at Emily who always seemed smarter and cooler, and more just knowing somehow. And how she thought that Emily was their fatherâs favorite and how she hated her sister a little for that. Amanda had often wished that she were an only child, like her friend Bethany.
âBut now that sheâs gone, it seems like the world can never be right again. I donât even know who I am without being different from her,â said Amanda. âAnd I loved her. I didnât even know it, but I did. And Iâm sure I never told her, not once.â
âYou didnât have to tell her,â Eloise said. âEveryone in this family always knew that love was the first feeling, the foundation. Everything else was second and temporary. Emily knew you loved her.â
âHow?â asked Amanda. âWe only ever fought.â
âDid you know she loved you?â
Amanda thought about this, then nodded an uncertain yes.
âHow?â asked Eloise.
âBecause she let me sleep with her in her bed when I was scared at night.â
âAnd she knew you loved her because you wanted to sleep in her bed,â said