not Otto. You didnât sleep with him after you dumped him. Did you? Break-up sex is so overrated. I am so not a believer in break-up sex.â
âNo. Not Otto.â
âWas it that guy we met at the club?â Milo laughed. âThe one with the nose?â
He meant the guy whoâd been grinding Colbyâs ass on the dance floor. He was hot, and it was true that the guy and Colby had left together. But only as far as the bus stop, where Colby had been overcome by a wave of nausea. Which made sense now.
Besides, Colby had already told Milo all of that.
Milo knew she hadnât slept with him.
Either he was slow figuring it out, or he already had and didnât want to say it. Then he did.
âNot from that one time?â
âYes. From that one time.â
âNot me.â
âYes, Milo. You.â
âNo way.â
âYes way.â
âNo way! Otto. It has to be Ottoâs.â
âItâs not Ottoâs. After I dumped him, I got my period. Then you and I messed around. And now Iâm pregnant.â
âBut Iâm gay .â
âAnd Iâm pregnant .â
âI canât be a dad!â
âHang on, Milo.â Colby stopped crying. She shifted from sad to mad in barely an instant. âNo oneâs asking you to be a dad .â
âBut youâre pregnant. With a baby. And youâve just told me that Iâm the dad.â
âConsider yourself a sperm donor, if that helps. Whatever! Iâm not even keeping it.â
âYou cannotââ
âI can so!â
âYou wouldnât!â
âI totally WOULD. Iâve got two more weeks to decide.â
The way they were arguing back and forth reminded her of when they were kids. Theyâd fought all the time. Usually over Gigi. Or the remote control. Both she and Milo always cared deeply about the outcome, no matter what they were fighting about. That much hadnât seemed to change.
âCole?â Milo barely whispered. âIâm so, so, so, so sorry.â
âFor what? For having sex with me?â Colby was only sorry that it hadnât made Milo straight.
âWe shouldnât have had sex. I know how you feel about meââ
âShut up, Milo.â Colby dropped her head into her hands. âIâm not in love with you. Not anymore.â
âBut you are,â Milo said quietly. âAnd thatâs okay. I love you, Colby. Just not romantically.â
Someone knocked on the door. When Colby didnât answer, they knocked louder, and then they started banging on the door.
âGet out! Iâve got it booked!â It was Jordan. Who hadnât gotten any nicer as she got more sober.
And she was not pregnant.
Or a mom.
But her mother had pulled some strings and got her in anyway.
Since barfing on her in the van, Colby had learned that Jordan was a drunk and a cutter.
âHurry up!â Jordan bellowed. âGET OUT.â
âI have to go,â Colby whispered.
âWhat are you going to do?â Milo asked.
âI donât know.â There was a long pause, during which Colby could practically hear everything that Milo was not saying out loud.
Jordan banged harder on the door. âI know itâs you in there, Barfy McBarfyson. Get the hell out.â
âGive me a minute, all right?â Colby kicked the door. âMilo?â
âOkay, Cole.â Milo sighed. âYou decide. Of course itâs up to you. Itâs your body. But let me know. Okay?â
His kind words made Colby cry even harder. She wanted him to scream at her. She wanted him to lecture her on how wrong abortion was. She wanted him to be an asshole and demand a paternity test. She wanted him to make her decision easier. Instead, he was making it harder. Just by being nice.
âI will.â Colby blew her nose. âI have to go.â
âCall me later?â
More banging on the door.
âI