hurries into the room.
Most classes, kids kind of straggle in, but in Mr. Catesâs creative writing class, everyone comes right in and sits down.
I sit near the front, and Adam slides into the seat next to me.
âHowdy, pardner,â he says in a bad cowboy accent.
âHi, Adam.â
âDo you have the book?â he whispers.
I tip my head toward my backpack.
Mr. Cates perches on his desk. He runs fingers through his curly hair to get it out of his face. He adjusts his glasses. âPage one hundred seventeen, people,â he says, carefully turning pages, like the book is really special, even though itâs just a paperback poetry anthology.
He started the pods-of-five day with a poem by E. E. Cummingsthat didnât make any sense at all, but then somehow it did, and we all had to write without rules, which was surprisingly hard. Especially for Adam.
Todayâs poem is by Shakespeare.
âGoing traditional today,â Adam murmurs.
âThis one will have rules,â I whisper. âYouâll love it.â
Mr. Cates starts to read in a rich, layered voice that lifts the poem off the page and delivers it personally to each of us.
Â
Not marble, nor the gilded monuments
Of princes, shall outlive this powerful rhyme . . .
Â
âPowerful rhyme!â he repeats, and the corners of his eyes crinkle as he smiles.
Â
But you shall shine more bright in these contents
Than unswept stone, besmearâd with sluttish time.
Â
âSluttish!â Josh Baum snorts.
Mr. Cates stares at Josh over his book, managing to communicate disdain without looking unkind.
âSorry,â Josh mutters.
Mr. Cates raises the book again.
Â
When wasteful war shall statues overturn,
And broils root out the work of masonry,
Nor Mars his sword nor warâs quick fire shall burn
The living record of your memory.
Â
He stops. âThat syntax is tricky. Let me paraphrase. Shakespeare says neither war nor ruin can destroy the record of your memory. And whatâs the record? Josh? Miranda?â
Miranda flips her hair. âUh, the record is the poem? Is that right?â
âSure is.â Mr. Cates beams. âNothing will destroy your memory because it lives forever in rhyme. This. Powerful. Rhyme. Next line.â
Â
âGainst death and all-oblivious enmity
Â
âWhat is âall-oblivious enmityâ?â
No one speaks up.
He prompts, âEnmity?â
âLike enemy?â Micah suggests.
Mr. Cates nods. âYes. Itâs a feeling of hostility. So then, what is âall-obliviousâ? Adam?â
âSomething about forgetting,â he says. âLike oblivion.â
âRight. So . . . forgetting is the enemy, and what defeats forgetting? Memory! Yes?â He looks around the room to make sure weâre all following and continues.
Â
âGainst death and all-oblivious enmity
Shall you pace forth; your praise shall still find room
Even in the eyes of all posterity
That wear this world out to the ending doom.
So, till the judgment that yourself arise,
You live in this, and dwell in loversâ eyes.
Â
He lets the silence hang in the room before he asks the now-familiar question: âWhat does it mean?â
I say, âIt means the person he loves will, like, live forever in the poem.â
Adam adds, âAnd the poem lasts even when other kinds of monuments are gone.â
Mr. Cates cocks his head to one side. âYou said âother kinds of monuments.â Is the poem a monument?â
Adam sits forward. âYeah, isnât it? The poem is a way to . . . to hang on to the person, even though theyâre gone. Thatâs what monuments do.â
âBut itâs kind of dumb,â says Kendall. âMonuments are, you know, stone and stuff that would totally last longer than a poem. I mean, a poem is just a piece of paper.â
âIndeed,â Mr. Cates