still hadnât returned. Then when the milking was done and Jonathan returned to the house, Mary said sheâd seen Aaron heading for town and figured heâd gone after Doc Haymes for Agnes.
So Jonathan went to sleep that night with the question unasked, but through the following day it remained in his mind just as heâd rehearsed it, and by the end of the day, when they were all three in the kitchen around the big old claw-foot table, he was tense from the weight of it.
One thing worked in his favor. Agnes Volence had had her baby last night, and Mary had that queer urge to talk about it, like she always did after news of a birthing.
âWeâll have to all go down there to visit, as soon as itâs respectable. Maybe the end of the week or so.â She was mending something she held on her lap, and she didnât look up.
Aaron was drawing a handful of cookies from an old molasses pail in the middle of the table. He glanced at Mary, reading her intention immediately.
âYou wouldnât be planning to do a bit of matchmaking while you pay your little social call, would you?â he asked.
âWhy, Aaron, no such thing. Itâs just common politeness to visit the new parents. You know that.â
âItâs not common politeness to go calling within a week of the birth. Agnes will moreân likely still be in bed.â
âAnd what better time to take a cake down there than when theyâre likely to appreciate it?â
She looked across at Aaron and put the thread in her teeth to bite it off. When she bit something off she was prepared to chew it, and he figured the sooner he made his peace with Pris the sooner Maryâd let up on him. He shrugged his shoulders and said, âWeâll see. What do you think, Jonathan?â
And then Jonathan did the strangest thing. He jumped. Or flinched, rather.
âJonathan?â
Mary couldnât see Jonathanâs hands, for the oilcloth cover hanging over the edge of the table hid them from sight. But she could tell he was wiping his palms on his thighs.
âIs something wrong, Jonathan?â
âWrong?â But Jonathan had a frog in his throat, and he had to clear it before he could continue. âJust that everybody is having babies but us.â
He didnât look at Mary, so he missed seeing her eyes drop quickly back to the work on her lap.
âExcuse meâ¦â Aaron rose from his chair as if to leave.
âNo. I want you to listen,â Jonathan said, staying his brother with a hand on his arm. âI got something to say, and itâs for both of you.â
Aaron glanced at Mary, but she kept her eyes on her needlework. He sat back down slowly.
âWeâve been married seven years now. Thatâs a long time. And there are no babies.â
âI think this is between you two, and Iâve got no place in it.â Aaron started to rise again, but a word from Jonathan stopped him.
âStay.â
And though Aaron stayed, he did so reluctantly while Jonathan went on.
âWe all here know what happened when we were boysâhow we both got the mumps, Aaron, you and me. They left meââhere Jonathan swallowedââI mean, we all know I canât father babies.â
âWe donât know that for sure, Jonathan,â Mary said. âI havenât given up hope.â
âWell, I gave up hope, Mary, and youâre just fooling yourself anymore,â Jonathan said.
âThereâs no call to hurt her,â Aaron said quietly, remembering what theyâd talked about the night before.
âWell, this place needs children, and they wonât spring from me.â
Jonathanâs palms were cold and damp on his thighs. His tongue, like a thick, swollen cork, threatened to stop up his mouth.
âBut you, Aaron, they could spring from you.â It came out half question, half something else. But it was out. Before he dissolved in his own