Andy said, neither frustrated nor hurried. âFine.â
âThereâs your way,â she said, âwhere everything is accidental, where the fact that the earth tilts on an axis, the fact that it has a moon to control the tides, the fact that it is just the exact distance from the sun to keep us warm without boiling us aliveâand even more than that, the fact that weâre here, the fact that we love each other and protect each other, is all an accident of timing and chemicals.â
âThatâs my way?â
âYes,â Melissa said. âThat is your way, because that is the way of Darwin, which says that we are no more important, no more intentional, than the dust on your desk. We might as well be like your caged mice for all the agency we have in the grand scheme of things.â
âAll right,â Andy said, neither aggravated nor impatient.
âBut hereâs your other option. A world in which life has purpose,â Melissa said. âGod put us here for a reason, and that reason is out in the world for us to discover. Thereâs a reason we can see stars in the sky. Thereâs a reason we can dig into the crust of the earth and find out what came before us. Thereâs a reason we were given the kinds of brains that would further your . . . scientific inquiry. Thereâs a reason for life. Thereâs a design behind it.â
Andy did not look at the clock. âI see what youâre saying, Melissa, but thatâs not a binary Iâm comfortable with.â
âYour world is the world of coincidence, of meaninglessness. You choose the world that would have us as specks of dust, as mice in a cage. Is that the kind of world you want to live in, Professor Waite?â
Andy took a breath.
âProfessor?â
He hated these rushes of memory, these forces that sucked him in like dark matter at the least convenient times, shattering him. But there he was, out of the shabby lab in the basement of Scientific Hall and instead in Miami, the apartment in Miami, four lushly carpeted and heavily air-conditioned rooms. It was night, and Lou, hugely pregnant with Belle, was lying down next to Rachel in her big-girl bed. Reading Richard Scarryâs Best Word Book Ever. Giggling together. Louisaâs belly rising up and down.
Specks of dust, dust to dust. Andy blinked his eyes, hard. He came back to where he was.
âProfessor?â Melissa tried again. âIs that what you want?â
âItâs not,â Andy said. âBut Iâve realized over the years that what I want doesnât really matter either way.â
âBut thatâs not true,â Melissa said. âYou get to decide what you want and you get to decide what really matters.â
The chill from the air-conditioning had made the hair on his arms stand up. For a moment, he lost his head. âMelissa, if you can come up with a reading list I approve of, Iâll do your independent study.â
âI can do that,â she said, cheerfully. âThatâs no problem.â
âBut you should know Iâm going to include some scientists I believe in. Henry Rosenblum, you heard of him?â
âYou want me to read Henry Rosenblum?â
âLots of him,â Andy said. âDawkins too. Those are my conditions.â
Why he was bothering with conditions at all he wasnât entirely sure, but if he was going to jump through hoops for her, then he would make her do the same for him.
Melissa sighed. âDo you think thereâs anyone else in the bio department who will take my project on?â
âIâd be shocked,â Andy said. âIn fact, Iâd be shocked if there was anyone else in the department who would ever let you finish a sentence about intelligent design.â She fingered her cross. âSo are you willing?â
âI guess I have no choice,â Melissa said.
âNot if youâre serious about this