his career to date. I couldnât, hand on heart, argue that it transcends the genre, and you probably only really need to read it if you have an Arsenal season ticket. And if there is one single Believer reader who is also an Arsenal season ticket holder, Iâll buy you a drink next home game. What the hellâIâll buy you a car.
I received How to Breathe Underwater and the Wilkie Collins novel in the same Jiffy envelope, sent to me by a friend at Penguin, who publishes all three of us in the UK; this friend is evangelical about both books, and so I began one, loved it, finished it, and then started the other. Usually, of course, I treat personal book recommendations with the suspicion they deserve. Iâve got enough to read as it is, so my first reaction when someone tells me to read something is to find a way to doubt their credentials, or to try to dredge up a conflicting view from the memory. (Just as stone always blunts scissors, a lukewarm âOh, it was OK,â always beats a âYou have to read this.â Itâs less work that way.) But every now and again, the zealous gleam in someoneâs eye catches the attention, and anyway Joanna, jaded as she is by her work, doesnât make loose or unnecessary recommendations. She keeps her powder dry.
She was right, luckily for her: How to Breathe Underwater is an outstanding collection of stories. Orringer writes about the things that everyone writes aboutâyouth, friendship, death, grief, etc.âbut her narrative settings are fresh and wonderfully knotty. So while her themes are as solid and as recognizable as oak trees, the stuff growing on the bark youâve never seen before. If you wanted to be reductive, âThe Smoothest Way Is Full of Stonesâ would collapse neatly into a coming-of-age story, with a conventional two-girls-and-a-guy triangle at its core. But one of the girls comes from a ferociously orthodox Jewish family, and the other one has a mother whoâs in the hospital after the loss of a baby, and the boy has this pornographic book stashed away, and the whole thing is so beautifully and complicatedly imagined that you donât want to boil it down to its essence. âPilgrims,â the first story in the book, makes you feel panicky and breathless, and is destined, I suspect, to be taught in creative writing classes everywhere. The moment Iâd finished I bought myself a first edition, and then another, for a friendâs birthday. Itâs that sort of book. Iâll tell you how much I liked it: one paragraph in the story âWhen She Is Old and I Am Famousâ contained the words âgowns,â âpumps,â âdiva hairdos,â âpink chiffon,â âsilk roses,â âcouture,â and â Vogue ,â and, after the briefest shudder, I read on anyway.
Iâm a couple of hundred pages into No Name , and so far itâs everything Iâd hoped it would be. It was sold to meâor given to me free, anywayâas a lost Victorian classic (and Iâd never even heard of it), and it really hits the spot: an engrossing, tortuous plot, quirky characters, pathos, the works. If you pick up the Penguin Classics edition, however, donât read the blurb on the back. It more or less blows the first (fantastic) plot twist, on the grounds that itâs ârevealed early onââbut âearly onâ turns out to be page ninety-six, not, say, page eight. Note to publishers: Some people read nineteenth-century novels for fun, and a lot of them were written to be read that way too.
I should, perhaps, attempt to explain away the ludicrous number of books bought this month. Most of them were secondhand paperbacks; I bought the Pete Dexter, the Murakami, and The Poet and the Murderer on a Saturday afternoon spent wandering up and down Stoke Newington Church Street with the baby, and I bought Leadville and Master Georgie from a bookstall at a local
Sonu Shamdasani C. G. Jung R. F.C. Hull