âNextâ appeared on the bottom right corner of the board, and when Haviland touched it, a box appeared over 8:25 PM on December 2, which read âPolice arrive at Kelley home.â
âIs this time correct?â Haviland asked.
âYes, it is,â Peyton said.
Haviland spun briefly to give the jury and the audience a good look, then leaned it against the table. âSo you came to the house and found evidence of firearm violence and a very angry Jacob Kelley,â he said. âWhat did you do next?â
âI called it in, and they started a manhunt for Brian Vanderhall. We put an APB out on his car and searched the neighborhood, but we didnât find him,â Peyton said.
âYou didnât find him? Was this a halfhearted search?â
âNo, sir. We went house to house for blocks in every direction, knocking on doors and searching yards. We alerted the departments in surrounding towns, as well as the New Jersey State Police. Nobody saw him.â
âHow long did the search continue?â
âUntil his dead body was found.â
âAnd in all that searching, did Mr. Kelley mention to you that there was a secret bunker, hidden underground, in which he and Mr. Vanderhall used to perform scientific experiments?â
âNo, he did not.â
âHe didnât suggest to you that Vanderhall might be hiding down there, evading capture?â
âNo, sir,â Peyton said.
âWhy do you think that is?â
âObjection,â Terry said. âHeâs asking the witness to speculate.â
âSustained,â Roswell said.
Haviland shrugged. âOne final question. What time did the police leave the Kelley home that night?â
âAt 10:55,â Peyton said.
Haviland picked up his whiteboard and pressed the âNextâ square again, causing a new box to appear over 10:55, which read âPolice leave Kelley home.â
âIs this correct?â he asked.
âYes, it is.â
âNo further questions, Your Honor.â
Haviland sat down. Terry leaped to his feet and practically ran to the lectern, where he threw down his notes. The pose of yawning indifference had disappeared in a moment. He glanced at me briefly, and his eyes were ablaze.
âMr. Peyton,â he said in the same strident tone I used to use to call one of my children to task when they misbehaved.
âOfficer,â Peyton corrected.
âAh yes. An officer of the law. Keeper of the truth. Mr. Peyton, in your eight years as a police officer, how many times have you been called to a scene of violence in someoneâs home?â
Peyton made a huffing noise. âI donât know. Hundreds.â
Terry held up a sheaf of papers. âAccording to police records, over five hundred times?â
âI would believe that, though I donât keep track,â Peyton said.
âAnd how many of those incidents have involved one or more angry persons?â
Peyton gave him a strange look. âIâm sorry?â
âCome on, Mr. Peyton. In how many of those incidents of violence in the home did you encounter someone who was, if I may quote you, âblazing madâ?â
âMost of them, I guess,â Peyton said.
âAnd how many of them resulted in someoneâs death?â
âNot many.â
Terry held up the papers. âFifteen?â
Peyton was getting a bit irritated. âIt could be. I donât remember the exact number.â
âSo is it safe to say,â Terry said, âin your expert opinion as a police officer, that when someone is angry, it doesnât necessarily mean he will kill someone?â
âNo, it doesnât.â
âMr. Peyton, when you encounter a man who you believe is a danger to himself or other people, what do you do?â
âWe take him into custody.â
âWould you include in your report your belief that you feared that person would do violence to
Douglas E. Schoen, Melik Kaylan