becauseâheâs decided Iâm his swan-song student. The last best one. He really wants me to be brilliant for him. If Iâm notâheâll feel as if heâs failed, too.â
âCan you do that well in it?â Jeff wondered.
âSure. I can see how heâs thinking. Itâs not even as if Iâm sure heâs wrong. I just donât look at it the same way.â
âBut to do that,â Sammy said, âyouâd have to lie about what you think is true. You canât do that, James.â
âWhy not? People do it all the time.â
âNot you.â
âBut if I donât, Iâll fail. Iâve never failed anything, in school.â
âYes, you have, in tenth grade, when you turned in that kid for cheating off of you, when you turned yourself in for helping him cheat. You failed that assignment with a zero.â
âThat was different. And besides, it was only one assignment, not the whole grade. I donât have anything lower than an A on my record, except for that one B. Ever.â
âThose are just grades,â Sammy said.
âGrades mean something. You know that.â
âMaybe, but I donât care becauseâjust because you get Aâs doesnât mean youâre the best person. All it means is youâre good at going to school. You canât use grades to mean anything, James.â
âSo you think I should fail it,â James concluded. âJeff, what do you think?â
âCanât you talk to your faculty adviser?â
âBut I donât want to make any trouble for Professor Browning. Itâs not as if he doesnât work, or care, or isnât thinking about what heâs doing; itâs not as if heâs a bad teacher.â
âWell,â Jeff summarized the situation, âit looks then as if you can pass, and belie yourself; or you can fail, and disappoint someone you would rather please, and lose your scholarship as well.â
âThatâs it,â James said. âIâve never failed a course.â
âThen pass it, get the A,â Sammy advised.
âBut I know how awful it feels to pretend to think what you donât,â James protested. âItâs likeâlike selling yourself into slavery, orâworseâselling your brothers and sisters, maybe, or your own children. I dunno, I donât have childrenââ
âIâm glad to hear that,â Gram said.
âBecause, if you canât be true to what you think . . .â Jamesâs voice faded away.
âFlunk,â Sammy advised.
Dicey didnât have any opinion about what James should do. She rolled over onto her back. Behind the sofa, the top half of the Christmas tree rose, looped around with strings of popcorn mixed with cranberries. The strings looked like jewelry, like long necklaces around a shaggy throat, like rubies set in among some strange undiscovered gem that was part pearl, part sea foam.
âGram?â James asked. âWhat do you think?â
âIâm sorry, James, I just donât seem to have any ideas.â
âI wish I knew,â James said. He leaned forward, resting his chin on his hands, his elbows on his knees. Dicey looked at the way his fingers laced together, and the bone of his jaw rested on the bones of his fingers. He really was worried about this. James looked at her and she shook her headâshe didnât have any idea. He turned to ask Maybeth.
Maybeth sat curled up, her long legs under her, her hazel eyes dark with worry. âIâm sorry,â she said.
James smiled. âItâs not your fault.â
âItâs not anyoneâs fault,â she said. âBut Iâm still sorry. BecauseâbutâI wish I could think. If I could thinkâbecauseâpeople who think keep thinking of things, when it doesnât seem as if thereâs anything but one way or the opposite.
Benjamin Blech, Roy Doliner