the crafts tables and start to interview random twins among the displays of bandannas, wind chimes, sandstone coasters, and crocheted hats.
Jessica and Jennifer, from New Orleans, are twenty-three and ebullient about Twinsburg. âItâs INSANE!â Jessica exclaims. âI LOVE it! All the TWINS! Itâs just the COOLEST thing. Iâm like a big
o
lâ tourist!â
âI was thinking, I feel less odd now,â says Jennifer, âbecause thereâs so many others like us. You immediately have something in common with someone else. Youâre hugginâ someone, and you donât even know them. You say, âHey Iâm a twin! Where you from?ââ
I ask them to try to describe their closeness. Jessica says, âI feel like
thatââ
she points at her sisterââis just an extension of me. Thatâs
me
over there, experiencing something different. Like astral projection, kind of.â
âSheâs my other half, you know,â Jennifer chimes in. âIf somethinghappened to her, I donât know what Iâd do. Itâs like slicing part of you in half. No one can make me madder; no one can make me happier.â
What about the perennial twins question: Were they competitive? âOh definitely,â says Jennifer. âI had to be better at it all, man.â She looks at Jessica. âI couldnât let you beat me.â
They even liked the same boy, and Jessica ended up marrying him. âWe were freshmen in high school,â Jessica recalls. âHe flirted with a lot of girls.â
âHe did,â Jennifer confirms. âHe was flirting with me and he was flirting with her and I got mad that he picked her, but I was happy for her. The Lord brought them together.â
Complicating matters, Jennifer had to chaperone her sister and the boyfriend sheâd lost on every one of their dates. âThe poor thing had to be the third wheel,â Jessica recalls. âBecause we were only fifteen when me and him started dating, and my Mom and Dad wouldnât let us be separated. It was like, âNo, sheâs got to go with you.ââ
Every date?
âPretty much,â Jessica says, a little embarrassed.
âThat wasnât fun,â Jennifer says grimly.
I wonder if it was wrenching for Jennifer to watch her sister end up with her crush. âNo, not at all,â she insists. âAs soon as he asked her out, Iâm like, âOkay, yâall were meant to be.â I was the maid of honor.â
These sisters seem to be lucky enough to have found romantic relationships (Jennifer has a boyfriend) despite their twinship. But for some reason, Twinsburg seems to draw a number of twinsâpredominantly maleâwho have never been married.
âI almost married once,â says Sam Zarante, fifty-one, dressed neatly in a button-down shirt. âMarie, my fiancée, didnât understand my being a twin. She thought my twin brother, Dave, and I were too close.â
âIâd be over, visiting, a lot,â Dave acknowledges.
âSo it would be the three of us, not two,â Sam adds. âHeâd be competition for her.â
Because she was never going to match their closeness?
âShe didnât understand it,â Dave says.
âI loved her,â Sam states.
âI liked her,â Dave chimes in. âI liked Marie. She was a good one.â
âWe did things together, the three of us,â Sam recalls. âBut after awhile, it came out: a little resentment. She wanted me to be her number one, you see. And I understand that. But I liked having him around.â
I ask when Sam and Marie broke up. âOh, itâs been awhile now,â Sam says.
Nineteen eighty-four. That was the last big relationship either twin had. For years, theyâve lived together in an Illinois suburb.
âNow, Abigail,â Dave says, addressing me suddenly. âI have to admit: