boy like you. You can have it if I can have that bottle you found. In fact, I donât even want the bottle. Iâd just like to have whatâs inside it.â
âUh, I donât think so,â Benny said.
âReally? May I ask why?â said the man.
âBecause Iâd have to talk to my grandfather first,â Benny told him.
âYes,â Jessie said, coming forward and putting her arms around her little brother. âWe would have to talk to our grandfather.â
The man pretended to look hurt. âOh, do we have to get him involved? Canât we just make a deal right here?â
âIâm sorry,â Henry cut in, âbut we really shouldnât be talking to strangers in the first place.â
The manâs smile suddenly came back. âThatâs very smart,â he said, although he didnât sound as if he meant it.
Then he reached into his pocket again and took out a business card. âWell, when youâre ready to make a deal, after youâve talked to your grandfather, please give me a call.â
âUmmm, okay,â Henry said, looking over the card quickly.
âHave a nice day, children,â the man told them as the window went back up. Then the car pulled away and was gone.
The others huddled around Henry to see what was on the card. There was nothing but a name and a phone number, and the name made their hearts jump:
Winston Walker
1-732-555-0241
âI think weâd better get back and tell Grandfather and Tom about this,â Henry said sullenly.
âI think youâre right,â Jessie replied. âLetâs go.â
CHAPTER 5
An Unwelcome Visitor
âI âm not surprised Walker turned up,â Tom said as he brought his fork to his mouth. He and Grandfather had made reservations at a nice restaurant called the Crabâs Claw Inn, right on Oyster Bay. âHe has obviously been after John Finneyâs treasure for years.â
âBut how did he get here so fast?â Violet wondered aloud. âDoes he live around here?â
âNo,â Tom said, âbut a man with that much money travels all the time.â Tom snapped his fingers. âHe can be anywhere in an instant. He probably saw the story in the paper.â
âSpeaking of which,â Grandfather said, reaching into his jacket pocket, âlook at this.â He opened the front page of a different newspaper. This one was called the Daily Tribune, and there was Bennyâs face again. It was the same picture as last time.
âThis is one of the biggest newspapers on the East Coast,â Grandfather said. âYour story is getting around fast. Pretty soon Winston Walker will have a lot of competition for that treasure.â
âSo what do we do?â asked Jessie.
âYou donât have to do anything if you donât want to,â Tom replied. âOr you can take Winston Walkerâs offer if you wish.â He looked at Benny. âItâs your piece of the map, Benny, so itâs your decision.â
Benny had been playing with his food but not eating it. The others were beginning to get worried. It was a rare moment when Benny wasnât hungry.
âI want to keep it,â he said firmly.
âSo then keep it,â Tom told him. âHave you found out anything about the other pieces?â
The children looked at one another with silent, somber faces, which puzzled Tom. âWhatâs wrong?â
âWe got a picture of one of them, piece number two, but the third piece, well . . . thatâs the one Winston Walker found, and . . . heâll never let anyone else see it or photograph it. Heâs the only one who knows what it looks like. Thatâs what the book in the Lighthouse Library said.â
Tom looked at Grandfather, then back at Henry. âSo what are you going to do?â
âWeâre not sure yet,â Henry admitted. âWe were thinking maybe we could put