forehead.
âYou asked me earlier if I was alright,â she said. âWhen we got off the ferry. And I said I was.â
I was puzzled. âAnd youâre not?â
Kate looked at me, her green eyes sad. She was trying to smile but it wasnât reaching her face.
âNo,â she said. âIâm not.â
We sat there quietly for a few minutes, watching the people stroll up and down the walk, their sunburnt faces glowing in the evening air. They looked comfortable, carefree, happy to be on an island off the coast of southern California. Everything that, at that moment, I was not.
âSo whatâs wrong?â I finally asked.
Kate folded her arms across her chest, tugging at the sleeves of her white cotton blouse. She turned to me, but her eyes were just missing my face.
âUs, Noah,â she said. âUs is whatâs wrong.â
Any time a girl breaks up with you, itâs painful. Always. But it may never be more painful than when you hear it for the first time.
I leaned back into the stone bench. âWhatâs wrong with us?â
She looked away for a moment, biting down on her bottom lip.
âIâm leaving next week,â she said.
âI know. So?â
She turned back to me. âSo what happens then?â
I shrugged. âYou get on a plane and go to Princeton?â
She frowned, faint lines of irritation tying up around her eyes. âNoah, you know what Iâm talking about.â
âNo, I donât,â I said. âWe came over here to have dinner and spend the night at your familyâs place. Now youâre telling me thereâs a problem. Between us.â I paused. âKate, I donât know what youâre talking about.â
She let out a sigh and shook her head. âFine. Iâm going to the other side of the country. Youâre staying here. How does that work?â
I shifted on the bench. âI donât know.â
âI donât either,â she said. âAnd thatâs the problem.â
âThatâs a problem with location. Not with us.â
She glanced at a group of junior high school kids ambling by, talking loudly and laughing. She looked back at me.
âWeâre eighteen,â Kate said. âWeâre going in different directions.â
Her words stung me. It didnât matter to me if they were true. They hurt. And I didnât like the feeling.
âYour mother write that speech for you?â I asked.
She rolled her eyes. âYou know better.â
âSounds like her,â I said. âAll of a sudden, we arenât compatible because youâre going to live in another state? That sounds exactly like her, Kate.â
We sat there quietly for a few minutes. Her parents had been a sore spot during the entire year weâd been together. They didnât approve of their daughter dating someone who wasnât going to an Ivy League school and whose family was dysfunctional at best. I hadnât made it any easier by playing the surly, disaffected teen. We had put Kate in a difficult spot. And until that moment on Catalina, sheâd always chosen me.
âMaybe it does sound like her,â Kate finally said. âBut maybe sheâs right, Noah.â
âSheâs right about me, you mean.â
âThatâs not what I meant and you know it,â she said. âBut is it realistic to think that weâre gonna stay together over the next four years, three thousand miles apart?â
I turned and looked at her, her eyes tearing into the heart that she had created.
âI donât know,â I said. âBut I never thought we wouldnât try.â
Her eyes fluttered, maybe surprised by what I said. She bit her bottom lip again. Tears formed at the corners of her eyes.
âNoah,â she started, but choked up and stopped.
I looked away, my throat tightening.
She cleared her throat and tried again. âNoah, they