might be lurking around and would try to shoot them, Jenny asked Nanette to have Kevin meet her outside the beach house. Then Jenny called her mother, who, in turn, called Jennyâs sister, Kim.
It was late in Tokyo when Kim got the call, just in from a night out with a friend. By that point, their mother was already making arrangements to fly to Newport Beach, where she ended up staying for several months, sleeping in the room sheâd once shared with Bill, so she could take care of her disabled son and try to hold her grieving family together.
Â
Â
As Jenny pulled up to the house in her gold Mercedes, Kevin was just coming out the front gate. Jenny was stymied why Nanette only peeked out the front door and then shut it quickly without coming outside to speak to her, console her, or try to share in their grief.
After striking out with Nanette and Kevin for more details, Jenny decided to go straight to the police. She arrived at Balboa Coves with her brother just after 9:00 A.M. Finding no detectives, she headed over to the station, where she found Van Horn and Voth, who had been trying to reach her too.
Like Kevin, the only person Jenny could offer as a possible suspect was Jacob Horowitz.
Asked about her fatherâs relationship with Nanette Johnston, Jenny said she knew of no problems, even given the difference in their ages. As far as she knew, her father wasnât seeing anyone romantically besides Nanette.
Anyone with access to keys was a suspect at that point, so the detectives asked Jenny where sheâd been around nine oâclock the night before. She said she was horseback riding with a couple people at the Nellie Gail Ranch in Laguna Niguel. Afterward, she headed home to visit with some friends, until nearly 11:00 P.M. After confirming her alibi, the police had Jenny take a lie detector test. She passed, as did her sister, Kim. Detectives crossed them both off the list of possible suspects.
Â
Â
Meanwhile, Nanette called her ex-husband, K. Ross Johnston, to tell him what had happened.
âBill has been shot,â she said.
âIâm sorry to hear that,â K. Ross said. âIs he going to be okay?â
âHeâs no longer with us.â
âOh, Iâm sorry. I didnât know.â
Nanette explained that Bill had been killed at the house after Kristoferâs soccer game, while she was out shopping, and she had receipts to prove it. But she said the police would probably be calling him to confirm her âalibiâ all the same.
âWhen they do, you donât need to tell them anything about Eric, because heâs not involved,â she said, referring to Eric Naposki, the professional linebacker and nightclub bouncer whom sheâd been bringing to Kristoferâs games for the past eighteen months.
Kevin McLaughlin didnât have anywhere to go that Friday. Because the police were still processing the house for evidence, they didnât want him wandering around, so he rode his three-wheeled bike around the community, presumably looking for Goldie, the familyâs golden retriever, who had run off after the murder. Nanette had to call Animal Control to see if they could find her. The dog turned up a couple of days later.
Told for the second consecutive night that he couldnât stay at the Balboa Coves house, Kevin called his girlfriend, Sandy Baumgardner, who worked in pharmaceutical sales, around four oâclock to come get him.
âSomeone came in last night and shot my dad,â Kevin said.
Sandy heard someone in the background telling him not to say anything more. âWho is that talking to you?â she asked, confused.
âThatâs Bill,â he said.
Now she was even more confused. I thought he just said Bill was dead, she thought.
âPut me on with Bill,â she ordered.
Sandy could hear Kevin explaining who she was to a man who then took the phone and identified himself as Detective Bill