Itâ
CALEB: Aargh. Stop. Anyone who didnât appear in episode one will be eliminated as a suspect.
DAVID: Uh, it actually wasnât in the first episode, come to think of it. It felt like the first episode. I figured it out toward the beginning. The killer may have been anywhere in the first several episodes. Anyway, what these twenty episodes build to is this: the men are always certain, and they always get it wrong. Basically, men know nothing and women know everything, intuitively. In some sense itâs a feminist parable disguised as a detective story, but itâs very delicately done. The merest bass line thrumming away. When you told your story about Jen cheating on her boyfriend and then Harv cheating on Jen and then Jefferson seeing his sister die and becoming a meth head and on and on, I was only slightly interested in it. It was just a âstory.â It has to flip over into something, into âX.â I need an X factor. Without that, itâs just life.
CALEB: Letâs talk about that former student of yours you keep writing aboutâthe guy who served time in prison for âshooting a dudeâ and whose prison credo âDo your own timeâ you donât like.
DAVID: âHis stoicism bores me.â
CALEB: Why keep writing about him?
DAVID: Iâm running out of ideas. Thatâs where you come in. Youâre fresh blood.
CALEB: Ha ha.
DAVID: Iâm serious.
CALEB: I want to know more about this guy. Did he kill or injure his victim? Was it assault? Was it murder? Manslaughter? How many years did he serve? In your books, the only question you ever ask is, âHow do we deal with the fact of mortality?â In essence, âWe die. What do we do about that?â Thatâs your modus operandi, but Iâm interested in why we kill.
DAVID: Why people commit individual murders or genocide?
CALEB: In Vollmannâs
Butterfly Stories
thereâs a restaurant owner in Phnom Penh who survived the Khmer Rouge, watched them kill his wife and children, and did nothing because if heâd showed emotion, he, too, would have been killed. Vollmann writes a sentence or two about suffering and moves on. I wanted Vollmann to stay.
DAVID: And what I loved is that Vollmann moved on. He knew we could fill in the blanks. Thatâs where the art comes in.
CALEB: I grew up around Cambodia, metaphorically. My parents went to Angkor Wat in 1956; they shot 16mm film. Mydad was in Saigon for a year, and he has a lot of books from that era. They subscribed to
National Geographic
. I remember this issue: âKampuchea Wakens from a Nightmare.â I was maybe twelve years old. After college, Cambodia became an obsession. I became engaged to a Cambodian woman; it lasted a year. Later, I went to Cambodia. Iâm now writing a Cambodian womanâs biography. Thatâs my X factor: suffering, the sociopath, the serial killer, atrocity, Pinochet, Pol Pot, Idi Amin, what motivates Ted Bundy?
DAVID: Do you somehow think that will get you closer to anything?
CALEB: It seems futile, but yes, I do.
DAVID: Yeah, letâs hear about another murder. You got the happy solution to murder?
CALEB: Whatâs frustrating is the vacuum. No oneâs interested in Cambodia, but we follow celebrity waistlines. Books about Cambodia and such: I read these books over and over again.
DAVID: What kind of booksâgenocide porn?
CALEB: Atrocity can become cliché, butâ
DAVID: Iâm much more interested in pulling back and seeing the big picture.
CALEB: Huh?
DAVID: My closest friend, Michael, has been spending the last decade writing a book called
Investigation into the Death of Logan
. His father died in Vietnam in â63, almost certainly a suicide. His wife, Norma, died at forty-six of cancer. And German soldiers in World War II had to return home from the Eastern Front because the war had made them insane. Michael is convinced that he and Norma decided she