know whatâmy fatherâs birthday? her father visiting? which he did every other week till he died when I was six, through I donât ever remember seeing him, there or any other placeâwhen she really went at it in the kitchen. The other times it was fairly quick and simple preparations and, occasionally, deli or chow mein brought in. Maybe we were going to my fatherâs sisterâsâIda and Jackâsâin Brooklyn for dinner that night. We did that sometimes. She cooked kosher, if thatâs the right expression, and my father, raised on it, still fancied it, especially on Jewish holidays. Anyway, he approached. I was around three or four at the time. So if it was a nursery school day and not a serious Jewish holiday and I wasnât home from school because I was sickâbut she never would have put shit in my face if I were sickâthen it was the afternoon. My nursery school for the two years was always in the morning. But what about my fatherâs business suit? Letâs just say he closed the office for the day and had a suit on because heâd just come back from a dental convention downtown. Heâs there though. I see him coming through the living room into the kitchen. I run through the breakfast roomâwhere we never had breakfast, except Sunday morning, just dinnerâto the kitchen. The kitchen was where we had breakfast and lunch. Friedaâs behind me. I donât remember seeing her, just always sensed she was. I hold out my arms to him. Iâm also crying. I donât remember that there, but how could I not be? I think a little of the shit was getting into my mouth. I donât remember smelling it but do tasting it a little. All this might sound like extrapolation, exaggerationâwhat I didnât smell but did taste. But I swear itâs not. Anyway, to it. Arms are out. Mine. Iâve a pleading look. I know it. I had never felt so humiliated, soiled, so sad, distressedâyou name it. Dramatic, right? Iâm telling you,â opening his eyes, âI felt absolutely miserable and this had to be evident to him. So maybe when he saw me he took that kind of defenseâlaughterârather than deal with it, try to comprehend it. But maybe not. Maybe he did think I tripped into it. So even though I was so distressed his first reaction might have been âOh my God, Howardâs tripped into shit.â Maybe he thought it was our dog Joeâs. Or dirt. That Iâd been playing in one of the backyard planters, or that it was paint on my face. Clay. But no play clayâs that color. Maybe it does get that way when you mix all the colors up. Anyway, my arms are out. Let me try to get beyond what Iâve so far canât remember about it. Past the blank.â Shuts his eyes. âArms. Heâs there. Kitchen. I run to him. Friedaâs behind me. Sense that. Iâm crying. Have to. Pleading look. He laughs. Blank. Blank.â Opens his eyes. âNo, didnât work. Most of my real old memories end like that. Like a sword coming down. Whop! Maybe hypnosis would get me past, but I tend to doubt those aids. Or canât see myself sitting there, just submitting.â
âBut your mother. Didnât she say it never happened?â
âTo me, yes. She says it happened to Alex. He says it did happen to him but nothing about a kitchen or pair of pants, which she seems to remember hearing he did it in, or my dad. That he was in a bathtub by himselfâone of the first times. Till then he had always bathed toe-to-toe with Jerry, but Frieda throught they were too grown-up for that so had it stoppedâwhen he suddenly shit. Two bigââ
âCome on, spare me.â
âSo he called out that heâd just made kaka in it. Frieda came, grabbed some of it out of the water and put it in his face. He said he never kakaed again in the tub or anywhere but in the potty, or at least that he doesnât remember