she’s
the one complaining for Alan.’
‘But that wasn’t the only time
you crossed a boundary, was it?’ said Krull.
Frieda met his eyes. ‘The case turned
out to be complicated. Alan was adopted. He discovered – no, I discovered and told him –
that he was an identical twin. He had a brother, whom he knew nothing about, and yet
they had an extraordinary psychological similarity and also a kind of connection, an
affinity if you will. They saw things in the same way, to some extent. Not surprisingly,
this discovery was disturbing to Alan. It was this brother who had takenMatthew: Dean Reeve – a household name now, the nation’s favourite
bogeyman.’
‘Who killed himself.’
‘He hanged himself under a bridge by a
canal over in Hackney when he knew he couldn’t escape us. However much Alan hated
the thought of his brother, he loved him as well. At least, he felt he had lost part of
himself when he died. He must have suffered a great deal. But that’s not what
Carrie means when she talks about me using him.’ Frieda looked at the three of
them with her large, dark eyes. ‘On one occasion,’ she continued, ‘I
talked to him as a way of entering his brother’s mind, of trying to find out what
his brother was thinking. Without telling him. If I’d told him, it wouldn’t
have worked.’
‘So you did use him?’
‘Yes,’ said Frieda. They were
all struck by her voice, which sounded angry rather than conciliatory.
‘Do you think that was
wrong?’
Frieda was silent for several moment,
frowning. She let herself slide back into the darkness of the case, among its shadows
and its inky dread. Her patient Alan had turned out to be the identical twin of Dean, a
psychopath who had abducted not only Matthew but, twenty years previously, a little
girl. And that little girl Joanna, once skinny and gap-toothed and shy, mourned without
cease by her family, had turned out to be the fat, lethargic wife of Dean, hiding in
plain sight, a victim turned perpetrator. It was Sasha’s DNA test that had proved
the obese, chain-smoking Terry was knock-kneed Joanna, that Dean’s willing
collaborator was also his victim. What was more – and this was what Frieda still thought
about when she stalked the London streets at night until she was so tired she could
sleep, and what she still dreamed about – Frieda’s discovery of the freakish
similaritybetween the twins had led to the abduction of a young
research student, whose body had never been found. She thought of Kathy Ripon’s
clever, likeable face and the future she would not have. Perhaps her parents were still
waiting for her to return, their hearts turning at every knock on the door. These
people, her judges, asked her if what she had done was wrong, as if there was a simple
answer; a truth that was not slippery and treacherous. She lifted her eyes and faced
them again.
‘Yes,’ she said, very clearly.
‘I wronged Alan Dekker, as my patient. But I don’t know if I was wrong. Or,
at least, I think I was both wrong and right in what I did. What Alan said to me on that
day led directly to Matthew. He saved a little boy’s life, there’s no doubt
about that. I thought he was glad he had helped. I know that time alters the way one
thinks about things, and I have no idea what he’s been through since then, but I
don’t understand why now, a year and a bit later, he would want to complain about
something that at the time he accepted. Can I say one more thing?’
‘Please.’ Professor Krull made a
courtly gesture with his thin, blue-veined hands.
‘Carrie talks about me putting my
career before her husband’s peace of mind and happiness. I did not further my
career. I do not work for the police and have no interest in being a detective. A young
woman disappeared because of my actions, and I live with that. But that is a separate
issue, not what we’re talking