play. Listen to the wordplay intro to âBaby, Letâs Play House,â which was really another way of saying, âWhat are we waiting for?â Or the way he steers âIâll Never Let You Goâ into a lascivious rockabilly coda (like âI Got a Womanâ in reverse).
By contrast, Wayne labored at his soft moods and avoided soapboxes of desire. Even though his acting was shallow, Presley would have uttered that line (âYou sure are cute when youâre angry,â) with comparative panache, with the self-possession that told you how corny it wasâand let the lady share in the sheer effrontery of it. And there are simply no Wayne analogs to the unbridled vocal freedom in Presley numbers like âI Donât Care If the Sun Donât Shineâ or âJust Because,â or hard rockers like âGood Rockinâ Tonightâ or âMilkcow Blues Boogie.â Perhaps to many, Wayne rocked hard on the inside, but Presley made sure all that presence was front and center: in the song, onstage, in his body.
It was in blues numbers that Presley began refining how (white) men could reimagine the idea of manhood: outbursts like âTrying to Get to You,â âHis Latest Flame,â or âOne Night.â This last number, the Smiley Lewis song about an orgy (available with the original lyrics on Reconsider Baby ), got edited from âOne night of sinâ to âOne night with youâ to assuage the RCA censors. But this edit doesnât suggest that Presley was âcleaning upâ his image as much as it reveals how he buffed up the surface to let the ulterior motives shine through. The songâs emotional hangover reflects the two singersâ differing racial attitudes toward sex: Presley brings a touch of guilt to what Lewis recalls with pure glee. But even without the dirty lyrics, nobody has much question what heâs singing about. In âAinât That Loving You Baby,â Presley lets loose with a beguiling sexual energy, the kind that tells you he would beat Wayne in any contest for any woman.
Presley turned seduction themes into metaphors for the way he inveigled his audience and for the fame and money that trailed his every move. Part of Wayneâs (and his ilkâs) resentment against Presleyâs fame was surely about how easy the young King made it all seem. Wayneâs ethic was about earning your pride, winning your standing among men by proving yourself through valor, heroism, and good deeds; sex was an invisible footnote. Presleyâs response was all about instant satisfaction, the pleasure of now, and a lack of anxiety about whatâs âproper.â In other words, Presleyâs sound is the saloon party Wayne left early to go on Indian lookout.
*Â Â Â *Â Â Â *
Hollywood tried to hitch its fortune to rock ânâ rollâs locomotive, but the train was already barreling out of town, leaving screenwriters and actors in catch-up mode for at least a decade. Beginning with Elvis Presley gyrating his hips unlike any man before or since, and Jerry Lee Lewis shaking his ducktail loose as he roared out âA Whole Lotta Shakinâ Going On,â rock songs poured from jukeboxes with new gender poses. From hairstyles to lifestyles, extremes were the rule: a whole generation of performers who came of age after 1955 either confronted the bland Norman Rockwell male-female stereotypes with bold poses of eccentricity or twisted the norms beyond recognition. Audiences werenât far behind.
Almost immediately, it seemed, the fault lines were everywhere. David Halberstam makes a crucial point about how TV father Ozzie Nelson tried to turn his son Rickyâs music into something that profited the Ozzie and Harriet show in 1957. Ricky Nelson loved rock ânâ roll for its independent spirit and powers of self-definition, and he was reluctant at firstâat sixteen, he just didnât feel