Ben and Kirstie down there when they came to stay with him in the spring. The beach and the sea were two of the delights of Bluebell Cove, as was the enchanting village surrounded by the rolling green fields of the Devonshire countryside.
If she were to put all that on to one side of the scales of life, and on the other side place living in a house she owned on the outskirts of one of the most famous cities in the world and the place where sheâd spent her childhood, but had sacrificed her life with Ethan because of it, which way would they tip? she wondered.
The wind continued to bite. She pulled her jacket more closely around her. What was the point of thinking those sorts of thoughts? Sheâd made her choice and her life was a mess.
Â
It was going dark in the cold winter afternoon and Ethan kept looking at the clock. Where was she? he wondered, the pale and drawn-looking stranger who not so long ago had been happy to live with him here, and now incredibly was back as a visitor, sleeping in the spare room instead of next to him in the double bed theyâd shared.
But, he thought bleakly, he wasnât there to watch over her in Paris, so why get all steamed up because Francine was late from a walk that theyâd done countless times before? Yet he couldnât help himself.
When their marriage had started to collapse sheâd been immovable in her desire to live in France and in the end heâd given up on her and after being stunned by her request for a divorce had agreed.
But she was different now, he thought, lost and vulnerable, but not so much that she hadnât been quick to remind him when heâd seen her in the square on Christmas Eve and joy bells had rung in his heart that she was only over on a visit to see the children.
He was going to have to keep a tight hold on his emotions because sheâd been the one whoâd wanted to end it, not him, and the pain of knowing she didnât love him enough to stay with him was unbearable.
Heâd gone upstairs to find the sheepskin coat that he wore in this kind of weather, having decided that makeof it what she would he had to check that no harm had befallen her, when through the bedroom window he saw her coming up the drive and hung the coat back in the wardrobe.
She was blue with cold and he thought it could only have been a desire to get away from him that had driven her out into the wintry weather for so long. What a fiasco Christmas was turning out to be, both of them wary as warring armies with undercurrents all the time instead of straight talking.
When he went downstairs she was in the hall, taking off her boots and jacket, and he said, âGo and sit by the fire. Iâll make you a hot drink.â
She was opening her mouth to refuse, he could tell. âJust do as I say, Francine,â he said, and she obeyed meekly.
He left her slowly sipping a hot toddy and went into his study, deciding that she didnât have to worry about him crowding her. It was the last thing he had in mind. Heâd been dreading spending Christmas without her and now that she was here he didnât know which was worseâhaving no communication at all or the stiff dialogue that was all they were left with.
Everything had always been clear and uncomplicated between them. Theyâd been in tune in every way, including fantastic sexual chemistry, until Francine had inherited the house in Paris and her overwhelming homesickness had shattered what theyâd had.
Â
The children had just been dropped off. Tired and happy, they were full of the day theyâd spent with their friends. As they were about to go up to bed Ben said, â Maman , we want to stay here where all our friends are.â
âYes,â Kirstie agreed. âWe like it in France, but we have no friends there.â
Ethan watched the colour drain from Francineâs face and thought that the children were quite unaware that theyâd just dealt