it, and she looked sad, like a little girl whoâs thinking sad thoughts, something about how strange life is, so he knew what was coming.
âDo you love me, Dick?â
That
was what was coming.
He began to eat the chili.
âThereâs two kids inside there sleeping. Weâve been together six years. We were together a year before that, before we got married.â
âYes, but do you love me?â
âO.K. I love you.â
âYou crook!â
âThatâs right.â
âWell, why
donât
you love me?â
âWeâve talked about this just about every night for seven years. Iâve told you all about it. Youâre welcome to lies if they make you happy. Youâre welcome to the truth if you insist on having it. Thanks for fixing the chili. Youâd better have some.â
The woman began to eat. She wasnât acting now, she was as serious as anybody could be, he would like to be as nice as possible, but she was always asking him the questions you have got to try to answer honestly and that meant that even if he tried to be nice she would know he wasnât telling the truth, and she wouldnât like it. She wanted lies to be true, thatâs all.
âWell, then, why isnât it possible for anybody really to love anybody?â she said.
âI donât know. Itâs certainly one of the things a man ought to try to get straight. Now, when you ask somebody if he loves you, you make it impossible for him to love you. The lousy question does it. And itâs not that somebody
canât
love somebody sometimes. He can. He can really love somebody, but he canât say he loves somebody because somebody asks him if he does. I mean anything he says at that time is either a lie or meaningless.â
â
When
do you love me?â
âWhen you shut up for a while. When it seems tome that somethingâs going on in your head that is quiet and lonely and straight and maybe even lovely. Maybe no such thing is actually going on, but I love you when there is only no evidence that it isnât. I really love you, then. I love you tenderly, then. I almost forgot all about the red and raw body youâve got that I enjoy so much, and I really love you, then.â
âWell, I donât want you to forget the body, either.â
âNeither do I want to forget it, but when you shut up and go about fussing with the kids in a nice way and quiet down and think about something besides the things youâre always thinking about, then I really love you. And I love you when you bawl. Thatâs the truth. Thatâs the only thing in the world that has ever made me helpless, the way you bawl, because you bawl like all the stupid little girls of the human race bawling. I swear to God it breaks my heart when you bawl. I never saw anybody bawl that way, not even kids, except our own, both of them bawl that way.â
âIâm going to bawl all the time. Iâm going to bawl right now while Iâm eating this awful chili.â
âGo ahead. And donât think I donât know youâre smart enough to do it any time you feel like it, too, because I do. Even so, even then, the way you bawl breaks my heart and makes me love you, makes me want to protect you, take care of you.â
âWell,
thatâs
something, anyway. Do you want the rest of my chili?â
âYou eat it. Youâve had nothing to eat since lunch.Christ, itâs almost two, and the kids are going to start running all over the place at six.â
âIgnore them. Iâve told you to ignore them or spank them and put them back to bed.â
âYouâre so God-damn smart. They canât be ignored. Theyâve got to be washed and dressed and given breakfast and turned loose in the yard, so they can live.â
âI donât want any more of it. You finish the rest of mine. I donât know how you can enjoy something so awful so
Patti Wheeler, Keith Hemstreet