nobodyâs fault. I know thatâs hard to believe, but itâs the only answer I have for you.â It was what he always said when I asked him to explain what was going on, but this time I stared at him, not saying anything, a terrifying idea suddenly overwhelming me. Was there some awful secret thatmy parents were keeping from me?
I kept staring. Like my mother, my father was very good-looking. His hair had some gray in it, but it was still thick, unlike most of my friendsâ fathersâ. He wore vaguely hipster glasses and, like my mother, he spent money on expensive clothes.
Had he been having an affair?
My dad was still talking. â. . . and Iâm sorry, Juliet. What matters is that your mom and I both still love you and Oliver very much. Weâre still your parents even though weâre not together anymore.â
He was waiting for me to say something, but the possibility that heâd been unfaithful to my mother was too awful for me to speak it. Instead, I cleared my throat, then forced myself to joke, âDid you get that from a book or something?â
âWhat gave it away?â My dad grinned at me and reached over to tousle my hair. âCome on. If we walk a couple of blocks, we can get an ice cream cone for less than four dollars.â
At the end of lunch, my dad had promised weâd see a lot of each other, more than we had when he was living at the house. Weâd agreed to have dinner once a weekâeither heâd come out to Long Island or Iâd stay in Manhattan and meet him after work.
The first week, heâd canceled because of a work dinner. The second week, heâd had to be out of town until Wednesday night, and heâd asked if I could do Thursday, but Iâd said I had my SAT tutor. The third week, the same thing had happened,except heâd asked if we could do Tuesday night.
âI. Have. My. SAT. Tutor,â Iâd said, slowly and carefully, like maybe he wasnât a native English speaker.
âI know you have an SAT tutor. Iâm sorry, but I thought it was Thursday night, not Tuesday night. Last week it was Thursday. So shoot me.â
âNo, Dad. Last week it was Tuesday and Thursday. And the week before that. And the week before that. In fact, Iâve been meeting my SAT tutor Tuesday and Thursday nights for the past six months . So shoot me . Or, wait. Youâre probably too busy to do that, either.â
He ignored my sarcasm. âWhat about Saturday night?â
âDad, I want to see my friends on Saturday night. Itâs the one night everyone doesnât have to be home early.â
Weâd agreed to have dinner this coming Wednesday. But now, here he was.
As soon as my dad was next to me, he reached for my hand. Unlike my mom, my dad didnât look physically different from how heâd looked before. His hair was the same, and he was wearing a blue shirt and a pair of khakis. Heâd probably been at work. He and my mom had sometimes fought about how much he worked. âAre you all right?â he asked.
âSeriously?â I asked, pulling my hand from his.
âIâm sorry.â He shook his head. âI meant . . . well, you know what I meant.â
I didnât, actually, but before I could ask him, the socialworker extended her hand and said, âIâm Jordyn Phillips.â I wasnât sure if she was intentionally interrupting my father and me or if she hadnât picked up on the tension between us.
He shook her hand. âMy sister-in-law called me and said my wife is here.â
My father used to refer to my mother as his wife all the time. I believe my wife made a reservation. . . . Iâm looking for my wife. . . . Have you met my wife? But now his saying my mother was his wife felt dishonest, even though I knew that technically they were still married.
I said nothing about their separation, not even when Ms. Phillips said, âMr. Newman, your wife