who checked the Hardens out of their rooms at the Langham â was mysterious only if the room clerk, a man Harden had never seen before, had told the truth. Assume that he lied and the mystery evaporated. It all hinged, then, on Evelyn Weber. Now consider the bogus telegram from Lear. It was presented to Harden at the hotel â presumably by a bellboy who could well have received it from the room clerk. Harden sent his follow-up wire from the Wigmore Street telegraph office, where Weber never knew of it. The response came back the following evening, when Weber was off duty. Thatâs the only reason Harden ever saw it. The murderous attack of the four-wheeler, I need hardly add, occurred just outside the hotel. Everything came back to the Langham and, by inference, to Weber. Clearly, he was also one of the hotel staff who overheard the heated dispute in the lobby between Messers Harden and Herbert â putting him in an excellent position to blame the formerâs death on the latter. Weber could have been merely an agent for Winter, of course, but the plain glass spectacles were a transparent disguise.â
Holmes sat back in his chair.
âAnd so ends another successful case for my annals,â I commented.
âThe case was indeed a great success,â Holmes said bitterly. âOnly the client died. No, Watson, I have scarcely covered myself with glory in this one. If you should ever chance to chronicle this adventure, let it be as the folly of an over-celebrated sleuthhound, not as some sort of triumph.â
He picked up his violin and commenced to scratch out a melancholy series of notes that seemed to match his mood.
âHolmes!â I cried after enduring some minutes of this. âThe Hamlet ! What in the world was the significance of the book John Vincent Harden grabbed in his final moment? You asked Hopkins for his theory, but you never gave your own.â
âDidnât I? Well, we can never know the truth for sure,â said Sherlock Holmes, looking up from his instrument. âBut having met the charming Stephen Winter, perhaps the answer lies in Act I, Scene V, if I recall correctly â âmeet it is I set it down/That one may smile, and smile, and be a villain.â â
Â
Also Available
Â