people talked about basketball, or if he seemed, at times, to have just a touch of a British accent, like one drop of color in a bowl of water, wellâhe was different, and good at being different.
Mr. Tate, my English teacher, had us read plays that spring, and when I showed him the ten-page scene Iâd written, he said, âItâs interesting. I mean that. People often say interesting when they mean boring. I donât. This work of yours really interests me.â
I liked Mr. Tate. Now and then he was too cute with us, just to show what a sport he was, but quite a few of the younger teachers were like that. He wasnât a real phony. He wasnât like Mel Mellers, who taught one two-hour class a week to all grades except the eleventh and twelfth. It was called the History of Social Ideasâor, maybe, the Social History of Ideas. Mel Mellers liked to pretend he didnât know any more than we did. One Friday morning he said, âThomas Jefferson! What a name! Do you dig it!â I didnât dare look at Elizabeth.
Mel, as we were supposed to call him, had a beard you could have hidden three piccolos in. Man! heâd cry, he was really with us! Starting out in a world weâd never made! Once in a while, heâd mention his postgraduate work at Princeton. But Mr. Mellers, Mel, was a pal.
Mr. Tate wasnât. I felt he meant what he said. Heâd read over what Iâd written and mutter to himself, then stab the paper with his finger and say, âThatâs right ⦠Now, here youâve gone off ⦠youâre just filling in space, but not here. Keep at it!â
I told Elizabeth how much I liked writing that scene, how it made up for the torture of mathematics. We were sitting in an empty classroom during the lunch period.
âCan I read it?â she asked.
âItâs not half done.â
âIâd like to see it anyhow.â
âI canât show it to you yet, Elizabeth.â
She put half a bar of chocolate on the desk I was sitting at. âNot even for that?â she asked, smiling.
âI canât. Really.â
âYou make it sound very important.â
âNo, no â¦â I exclaimed quickly. âItâs that Iâm scared to have anyone see it. Tate has to. But if I start showing it to youâor other peopleââ
ââHugh Todd, you mean.â
ââthen I wonât finish it. Youâll like it, or you wonât like it, and then Iâll start working on it with you in mind. Even if you didnât say a word, Iâd be wondering what you thought. Do you see what I mean?â
I couldnât look at her. I was half lying. That means I was lying. I had already shown it to Hugh. I wanted to make it right for him. I couldnât have explained that to Elizabeth. I couldnât explain it to myself. It would have hurt her feelings if she had known. We were best friends. But between Hugh and me, there was something else. I couldnât get hold of what it was; what I told myself was that he had a real interest in me. I was someone different for him than I was for Ma, or even had been for Papa when he was alive. When I was with Hugh, I traveled a little distance from myself, and he and I watched and thought about the familiar Victoria Finch who began to seem somewhat unfamiliar.
After Iâd first had the idea of writing a scene for English credit, Iâd told Hugh about it on one of the afternoons he stopped by my house for a while. Now, when we were both in the lunchroom, he with some of the other juniors in his class, and me with Elizabeth, heâd look straight at me suddenly and Iâd look back. We wouldnât smile, or wave, just look. I knew, at those moments, that we were thinking about the scene I was writing, what he had begun to call âour play.â
I loved to look at Hugh Todd. The whites of his eyes were the clearest Iâd ever seen, and the irises were