donât know what to say,â I said, smiling across the table at her.
Iâd put a plate of cut-up fruit on the table because I knew Rebecca had been instructed by her doctor to restrain her sweet tooth a little. âWell, thatâs easy,â she said, reaching for some apple slices. âYou say âyes.ââ
âOkay. Yes.â I gave her arm a squeeze and she beamed at me.
I was touched by the generous offer, which I suspected had originated with Rebecca. Everett was just as kindhearted as his wife, but Rebecca had an extra soft spot when it came to anything involving kids.
She leaned down for a moment to speak to Hercules, and I realized I couldnât do it. I couldnât ask her about the missing items from the co-op store because I was certain sheâd had nothing to do with the thefts. It made no sense. Looking at Rebecca smiling down at Hercules, I found it hard to imagine her looking furtive while she browsed in the shop and stuffed a couple of placemats in her tote bag. There had to be some other explanation for what had happened.
âDo you think Eddie would agree to come to the party?â Rebecca asked. âHeâs so good with children.â
âI think he probably would,â I said, getting up to refill my cup. Now that he didnât have all of Rebeccaâs attention, Hercules had started nosing around the canvas bag next to her chair.
âLeave that alone,â I said quietly to him.
Hercules immediately sat down, the picture of innocence, but when I turned back to the counter, from the corner of my eye I saw him nudge the bag with his nose once more. I swung around again. âCut that out!â I said sharply.
âOh, he canât hurt anything,â Rebecca said.
âYou spoil him and Owen,â I said, frowning in mock annoyance at her.
Since my attention was diverted, Hercules decided it would be a good time to give the tote a poke with his paw. That was enough for me. I moved to pick him up just as the bag slid down the chair leg and toppled over. A small plastic baggie fell out. Hercules swatted it with a paw and it skidded across the floor, stopping at my feet.
âVery, very bad,â I said to the cat, who didnât look the slightest bit repentant. I bent down to pick up the baggie. Inside were five chocolate-dipped chocolate chip cookies that I recognized as coming from Fernâs Diner. I straightened up and looked inquiringly at Rebecca.
She didnât quite meet my gaze.
âWhatâs going on?â I asked.
There were two spots of color high on her cheekbones. âI donât suppose you would believe that I doesnât know how those cookies got in my bag?â she said. The look on her face reminded me of Owen the last time heâd decapitated a Fred the Funky Chicken and scattered bits of dried catnip all over the living room.
I pointed a finger at Hercules. âThere will be consequences.â
He made a soft murp and seemed to shrug, almost as though he were trying to say he didnât really think so.
I sat down again, setting the cookies on the table, and reached over to catch Rebeccaâs hands in mine. âWhatâs going on?â I asked again.
Rebecca pursed her lips and met my gaze this time. âIâm a weak old woman.â
I shook my head. âYou are not old and you most definitely are not weak. Youâre one of the strongest womenâone of the strongest people I know.â
That got me a small smile. âDo you remember me telling you that my doctor wants me to cut back on the sweets a little? And by the way, my mother had a sweet tooth and she ate cookies until the day she died and she was just fine.â Her chin jutted out just a little. Iâd seen that defiant pose before.
I waited without speaking. Rebecca cleared her throat. âI guess that isnât really relevant,â she said after a minute. âIâm, uh . . . Iâm