father if he would narrate the Bewitched pilot. In the interview she granted to Ronald Haven for the Jordan laserdisc, she referenced her dadâs decline to speak life into Bewitched , calling his response, âvery strangeâ:
âNo ⦠I donât think so.â
âWhy not?â
âItâs your show.â
âAh, ok. All right.â
Elizabeth was disappointed, and she later told him so. She would have enjoyed him kicking off Bewitched , her new series in 1964, just as he had given a jumpstart to her TV career when she made her small-screen debut on Robert Montgomery Presents in 1951.
For Lizzie, success was at times a burden, especially when it came to public revelations. For one, her age was a sensitive issue, cloaked in a chicane. But as author and genealogist James Pylant explains, âCelebrity genealogies are always hard to trace.â In 2004, Pylant authored The Bewitching Family Tree of Elizabeth Montgomery for genealogymagazine.com . âBiographical data abounds,â he said, âyet thereâs no guarantee of accuracy.â
Elizabeth played into such wriggle room. Various studio and network press bios document her birth year as 1936 and 1938. In reality, it was 1933, as recorded in the State of California, California Birth Index, 1905â1995, published in Sacramento by the State of California Department of Public Health, Center for Health Statistics.
When she died in 1995, a few obituaries listed her age as fifty-seven, trimming five years off her birth date. Others offered conflicting details about her marital status: some said she was single at the time of her demise; some said she was survived by her fourth husband, Robert Foxworth.
But the âmarital mystery,â as Pylant put it, was orchestrated by the self-protective Lizzie, who kept a step ahead of the press. She viewed her relationship with Foxworth as confidential. Even their marriage in 1993 was shrouded from the media. The event took place at the Los Angeles apartment of her manager Barry Krost and not a soul knew about it until after the fact.
Nevertheless, she appears on the Social Security Death Index as âElizabeth Asher,â the surname of her third ex-husband, Bewitched producer/director William Asher. There, at least, her birth date is correctâApril 15, 1933âalthough âElizabeth A. Montgomeryâ is the name listed on her death certificate. The âAâ is either for âAsherâ or âAllen,â the maiden name of her mother, actress Elizabeth Allen.
According to A&Eâs Biography, Elizabeth Montgomery: A Touch of Magic (which originally aired on February 15, 1999), Lizzieâs middle name was âVictoria,â a moniker sometimes linked with royalty, as is the name âElizabethâ itself.
But that fits. From the mid-1970s until her demise in 1995, she was known as Queen of the TV-Movies . On Bewitched, Samantha was crowned Queen of the Witches (in the episode, âLong Live the Queen,â September 7, 1967); before that Aunt Clara âs (Marion Lorne) bumbling magic mishaps forced Samâs introduction to Queen Victoria (Jane Connell in âAunt Claraâs Queen Victoria Victory,â March 9, 1967).
Before Lizzie basked in the sparkle of stardom as Samantha , she was born in the shadow of Robert Montgomeryâs fame. The story of who she was begins with him; the seeds of who she became were indelibly planted by this versatile actor and political idealistâa father who was just as complex as his daughter; a daughter who had a father complex.
Five years after his marriage to Broadway actress Elizabeth Allen on April 24, 1928, Lizzie was born into her privileged childhood, at the peak of his film popularity.
Talented, handsome, athletic, rich, and famous, Robert had the right social credentials, coupled with a solid intellect. Before his stable career on the small screen of the 1950s, he was a feature film