with a firm hand. She lifted the tray and brought it to the table where they sat.
âHe had his back to the door, of course,â she continued, pouring out, âbut he was sprawled in his chairâhalf out of it, actually. So I ran over, but as soon as I saw his face, I knew it was no good.â
She set a mug in front of Gibbons and one in front of Bethancourt. âHelp yourself to scones,â she said. âI make them myself.â
Both men, who had assumed she was preparing the tray for someone else, were rather taken aback.
âIt was very kind of you to go to all this trouble,â said Bethancourt.
âVery kind,â echoed Gibbons. âYou really didnât need to bother.â
She looked surprised. âEverybody eats in a kitchen,â she said and, taking her own mug of coffee, moved to sit between them, tucking one yellow leg up beside her on the chair. âWhere was I? Oh, yes. I tried to feel for a pulse, but, quite frankly, Iâve only the vaguest idea where one is and I mightnât have found it if it had been there. I couldnât help thinking he was dead, and it rather unnerved me.â Her matter-of-fact tone faltered for a moment, but in the next instant she had collected herself and continued, âAnyway, I rang 999 and then went up to tell Miss Wellman what had happened. Then I went out front to wait for the ambulance.â
Finding a corpse had clearly disturbed her, but she showed no emotion about the death itself.
âYou donât seem very grieved,â said Gibbons carefully.
Kitty looked surprised. âItâs been over a month,â she pointed out. âI was upset at the time, of course, and sad to see him go, but itâs not as if we were close.â
âThis is delicious coffee,â put in Bethancourt, reaching to butter a scone.
She grinned, her eyes twinkling mischievously. âNaturally,â she replied. âThey donât pay me for nothing, you know.â
Bethancourt grinned back and took a large bite of scone. âDid Mr. Berowne take it this strong?â he asked around the mouthful.
âYes. Oh, I see what youâre getting at. Well, I donât know what the poison would have tasted like, but if this would have masked the taste, then it did.â
âDid Miss Wellman seem surprised when you told her?â asked Gibbons.
âQuite,â she answered. âIn fact, she thought I must have made a mistake and hurried down to see if she could do anything. Of course, at the time I assumed heâd had a heart attack or something like that. And I forgot to sayââ here her tone sharpened, ââthere is absolutely no possibility whatsoever that anything but coffee and hot water got into that pot in this kitchen.â
âIt does seem more likely,â answered Gibbons diplomatically, âthat the poison was introduced in the study.â
She nodded and sipped her coffee.
âNow I understand,â continued Gibbons, âthat Fatima Sathay, the daily help, was in the kitchen during this period?â
âFatima was our daily help,â said Kitty wryly. âSheâs only seventeen, and her parents made her quit when the news came out about the murder. Poor Mrs. Simmons is working herself to the bone to get everything done herself.â
âBut Miss Sathay was here on the day of the murder?â
âThatâs right,â she answered. âFatima was polishing the silver that morning. Sheâd brought it all down and was here at this table the entire time. She was at it when I took the tray up and she was still here when I went up and found him. She couldnât possibly have left without my seeing her.â
Which also, reflected Gibbons, gave Kitty herself the next best
thing to an alibi. It was barely possible that she had re-entered the study after Annette had left the house, but by Fatimaâs account Kitty had been gone for less than five