only for Amyâs four years at Syracuse. They had been renting the same summer house for two weeks in August on Fire Island since Meg was a toddlerâand the fee somehow barely went up. And, of course, the one thing that made their life in Manhattan infinitely more livable than those of a lot of their friends: the beautiful, three-bedroom, prewar apartment with a view of the river that Yardley provided them for a fraction of the market value.
They had been lucky. But their daughters were about to become even luckier. So it surprised her when Hugh said that he liked both Stowe and Andy, âdespite the money.â
âDespite the money?â Meryl said. âDoesnât every parent dream of their kid marrying rich?â
âNo,â Hugh said, frowning at her. âThey dream of their children being happy.â
âYes, well, you have to admit, money helps in that regard.â
But in saying that, she felt like she was betraying some core value they had once sharedâa pact they had made to live a life in the pursuit of art and culture. Certainly Hugh, a high school English teacher, and Meryl, with a career in book publishing, were not motivated by making a fortune. A fact that made the extravagant wealth of their daughtersâ partners all the more curious.
And though she hated to admit it, her life with Hugh suddenly seemed provincial, as if theyâd raised their girls on a farm. At least, she was afraid thatâs how it seemed to the Campions.
Maybe Hugh sensed that attitude as well, because he certainly didnât seem to share her excitement about the engagement.
âCan you at least pretend to be looking forward to dinner tonight? Between you and my mother, I feel like Iâm in this thing alone.â
âIâm sorry. Iâm preoccupied.â
She wanted to tell him to snap out of it, but he looked so defeated. So she put her hand his arm and softly asked, âWhatâs going on?â
âItâs just work stuff,â he said, shaking her off.
Then she remembered: the call earlier in the day when sheâd been running to her motherâs. Janell South.
Janell South was a senior who had come to Yardley two years earlier, a scholarship student. There werenât many of them at Yardley, but the ones who made it there and lasted tended to be exceptional. She had grown up in the Bronx, shuttled between foster homes, before recently settling with her adult half sister in Harlem. According to Hugh, she was a talented writer who shared his passion for the American classics.
âWhatâs the problem?â
âJanell handed in a plagiarized paper,â Hugh said.
âOh, Hughâare you absolutely certain?â
âI recognized entire passages from McKnightâs book on Hawthorne.â
âIâm sorry! I know this is a huge disappointment. Will they let her finish out the semester?â
Yardley had a zero-tolerance policy toward cheating, a hard-and-fast rule that was enacted in the wake of massive cheating scandals at Stuveysant High School and Horace Mann. Hugh sat on the advisory board that had passed the measure.
âIâm sure they wouldnât.â
âYou mean, wonât.â
âNo, I mean if I had reported it, they would expel her immediately.â
Merylâs eyes grew wide. Just last year, Hugh had overseen the dismissal of Todd Boswick, a junior who cheated on the Regents Exam.
âYou didnât report her? Hugh, you canât be serious. You canât just take it upon yourself to make exceptions to the rules. Thatâs why you and the board voted for zero toleranceâto take the guessing and favoritism out of it.â
âThis is different.â
Todd Boswick, son of a hedge fund billionaire, was barely passing his classes. He skipped class, routinely got busted for having his cell phone or other contraband, and he talked back to teachers. Todd was a kid who thought the rules
Aziz Ansari, Eric Klinenberg