attacking someone who was helping Sybil and then insisting she come home and send help for you? What was going on?â
Gwen first looked at her oldest sister and then glanced at Lillian, Bonnie, and Sybil, too. This would not be easy to explain, so the least said the better.
âNothing really,â she fibbed. âIt was all a mistake that was quickly cleared up when Bray arrived and I found out the gentleman is not Mr. but His Grace.â
Gasps sounded all around.
âYou struck a duke with a basket?â Louisa asked.
âYouâre in big trouble,â Bonnie declared.
âBut he told me his name was Crispin,â Sybil complained.
âWhatâs going to happen to you?â Lillian asked. âWill you be punished?â
âNo, no. Of course not,â Gwen answered. âI apologized to him and itâs all forgotten, so thereâs no need to mention it again. To anyone. Ever.â
âI canât believe you really hit a duke?â Louisa said. âWhat could have caused you to do such a thing?â
Gwen didnât know if she needed to clarify what had happened or somehow try to defend herself. She really didnât want to do either. After sucking in a deep breath, she said, âAt the time I didnât know he was a duke. Besides, I didnât hit him very hard.â That might have been more than a slight prevarication. The scratch under the dukeâs eye was more of a wide red scrape and it wasnât little. âAnd I wouldnât have hit him at all if Sybil had not been where she shouldnât have been and fallen out of that tree,â Gwen said, hoping to take some of the pressure off herself by putting it where it rightly belonged, on Sybilâs slender shoulders.
âYou hit Crispin with the basket hard enough to hurt him,â Sybil argued. âI saw the welt on his cheek and it was big.â
Every set of eyes in the room went to the broken basket sitting on the night table. Gwen threw her shoulders back. She had to change the subject.
âSybil, he is Your Grace,â Gwen corrected. âYou canât call him Crispin.â
âBut he told me that was his name,â she said. âI donât have to call Bray Your Grace and heâs a duke.â
âThat is because Bray considers himself your brother,â Louisa added. âHe gave you permission to call him Bray. He is family and family members have rights others donât have.â
âAnd, Bonnie,â Gwen said, turning to her youngest sister, âyou must remember that, too, in case you are below stairs and get to meet him when he comes to dinner tonight.â
More gasps flew around the bed.
âHeâs coming to dinner tonight?â Sybil asked.
âI want to meet him,â Bonnie said.
âMe, too,â Lillian echoed. âIâm happy to call him Your Grace.â
âI will, too,â Bonnie added. âI promise.â
âWell, I guess heâs not too upset with you for striking him if he accepted your invitation to dinner,â Louisa said, giving Gwen a look that said she knew there was more to this story. âIt was the least you could do.â
Gwen could see the wheels of romance turning in Louisaâs mind. Wanting to put a stop to her thinking, Gwen said, âI didnât invite him. I wouldnât have. Bray invited him to thank him for helping Sybil. He said you would want him to.â
âAnd heâs right. Itâs the polite thing to do.â
âSomeone will have to carry me downstairs so I can thank the duke myself,â Sybil insisted.
âNot tonight, you wonât,â Louisa said. âThere will be no going below stairs for you.â
âWhy?â Sybil complained. âIâm the one who met him first.â
âTwo reasons,â Louisa said. âOne, you left the house without permission and without anyone knowing. There must be a punishment for