somehow he got up the nerve to ask her to marry him and she agreed. Gratitude. He endeared himself to her. But it was essentially a father-daughter relationship, no more than that. He was a widower. Of course, her becoming Jewish was not as serious as it might have been. I instructed her for two weeks and then her interest waned. But I got to know her a littleâonly why should this matter to the police?â
Detective Masuto told him why it mattered to the police, and the rabbi ate his yogurt and listened with interest, and then when Masuto finished, said, âI called the house when you telephoned me. Mrs. Greenberg was still asleep. I think I had better go over there now. Sheâll need someone to lean on.â
âYou donât appear surprised.â
âAt murder?â asked Rabbi Gitlin. âBut you donât know that it is murder, and nothing should surprise us in this world.â
âI am not completely at home with the social relationships and overlaps of your Western religions, but would a man like Mr. Greenberg, under great stress, cry out the name of Jesus Christ?â
The rabbi shrugged. âWho knows what any of us would do under great stress.â
âMay I ask you an unspeakable question?â
âOf course,â the rabbi smiled. âBut you must forgive me if I give you an unspeakable answer.â
âIn your opinion, could Mrs. Greenberg have murdered her husband?â
âNot unspeakable, but interesting. You do not ask whether I think she had reason to, incitement toâbut only whether she could have. But how could either of us, Detective Ma suto, even know what the human mind and soul is capable of? Murder is a terrible ultimate. It is the ghost, the monster that lurks wherever human beings live. It is not your question that is unspeakable, but murder itself. I cannot accept the proposition that Al Greenberg was murdered, but if he was murdered, then that defines the murderer. You told me that you met Al Greenberg?â
âSeveral times.â
âThen you must understand that if he was murdered, then your murderer is without heart or compunction, someone who will stop at nothing. The very thought of such a murderer is particularly terrifying. I would be relieved if you told me your own thoughts.â
âThat there was no murder?â
âI would like to think that, Detective Masuto.â
âHave you time enough for me to call Dr. Baxterâour medical examiner? He should be at the hospital now, completing the autopsy.â
âIf you wish.â The rabbi pointed to his telephone, and Masuto dialed the hospital and was transferred to the autopsy room. A nurse answered and asked whether he would wait a moment or two, since Dr. Baxter was washing up. The rabbi watched Masuto thoughtfully. Then Baxter got on the phone and told him testily that he had spent three hours on a lot of nonsense.
âWhat did you find?â Masuto asked.
âThat he died of a heart attack.â
âSupposeâDoc, suppose that he fell down and someone held a pillow over his face for a minute or two. Would it show up in the autopsy?â
âNo.â
âJust like that?â
âJust like that. No. What do you want, an autopsy or the kind of nonsense you read in novels?â
âBut the pillow would cause his death?â
âWell, of course it would. You donât breathe, you die.â
âThat would be murder.â
âNot with me on the witness stand, it wouldnât. I told you he died of a myocardial infarction. That still goes.â
âBut the pillow?â
âI could invent a lot of other ways to kill him, and it would still be a heart attack. So youâre on your own, my lad.â
Masuto replaced the telephone and turned to the rabbi, who smiled sadly. âIâm afraid I prefer to agree with your doctor,â he said. âIf you want a murder, Mr. Masuto, you must find