getting my Ph.D. It was as the chairman of the newly formed comparative-literature department that Arthur brought me from Stanford to Stony Brook eight years ago. He is nearly fifty now, a wry and charming gentleman, and for an academic uncommonly, almost alarmingly, suave in manner and dress. It was his social expertise as much as our long-standing acquaintanceship that led me (and Dr. Klinger) to settle finally on Arthur as the best person with whom to make my social debut following the victory over the phallic cravings of my nipple. I also wanted Arthur to come so that I could talk to himâif not during this first visit, then the nextâabout how I might maintain my affiliation with the university. Back at Stanford I had been a âreaderâ for one of the enormous sophomore classes he lectured in âMasterpieces of Western Literature.â I had begun to wonder if I couldnât perform some such function again. Claire could read aloud to me the student papers, I could dictate to her my comments and grades ⦠Or was that a hopeless idea? It took Dr. Klinger several weeks to encourage me to believe that there would be no harm in asking.
I never got the chance. Even as I was telling him, a little âtearfullyââI couldnât help myselfâhow touched I was that he should be the first of my colleagues to visit, I thought I could hear giggling. âArthur,â I asked, âare we aloneâ?â He said, âYes.â Then giggled, quite distinctly. Sightless, I could still picture my former mentor: in his blue blazer with the paisley lining tailored in London for him by Kilgore, French; in his soft flannel trousers, in his gleaming Gucci loafers, the diplomatic Dean with his handsome mop of salt-and-pepper hairâgiggling! And I hadnât even made my suggestion about becoming a reader for the department. Gigglingânot because of anything ludicrous I had proposed, but because he saw that it was true, I actually had turned into a breast. My graduate-school adviser, my university superior, the most courtly professor I have ever knownâand yet, from the sound of it, overcome with the giggles simply at the sight of me.
âIâmâIâDavidââ But now he was laughing so, he couldnât even speak. Arthur Schonbrunn unable to speak. Talk about the incredible. Twenty, thirty seconds more of uproarious laughter, and then he was gone. The visit had lasted about three minutes.
Two days later came the apology, as elegantly done as anything Arthurâs written since his little book on Robert Musil. And the following week, the package from Sam Goodyâs, with a card signed, âDebbie and Arthur S.â A record album of Laurence Olivier in Hamlet.
Arthur had written: âYour misfortune should not have had to be compounded by my feeble, unforgivable performance. Iâm at a loss to explain what came over me. It would strike us both as so much cant if I even tried.â
I worked on my reply for a week. I must have dictated easily fifty letters: gracious, eloquent, forgiving, lighthearted, grave, hangdog, businesslike, arch, vicious, wild, literaryâand some even sillier than the one I dispatched. âFeeble?â I wrote Arthur. âWhy, if anything it is evidence of your earthy vitality that you should have laughed yourself sick. I am the feeble one, otherwise I would have joined in. If I fail to appreciate the enormous comedy of all this, it is only because I am really more of an Arthur Schonbrunn than you are, you vain, self-loving, dandified prick!â But the one I finally settled on read simply: âDear Debbie and Arthur S.: Thanx mucho for the groovy sides. Dave âThe Breastâ K.â I checked twice with Claire to be sure she had spelled thanks with that x before she went ahead and mailed my little message. If she mailed it. If she even took it down.
The second crisis that threatened to undo me and