came; for me, there was only pulsing discomfort, which faded to a dull throb. The next day, in Gabeâs room, I held his chest as he lurched and rocked above me; and then I was the one who was lurching, rocking, tentatively at first and then with a voraciousness I didnât know I had. We moved together brutally, our teenagerâs need as aggressive as it was ravenous, shoving until we seemed less to be having sex than pushing outside our own skins. It was as though there was something to be found beyond sex and we were running for it, clasped together but somehow in competition. Which is not to say it didnât feel shared; we were together in those moments, the only ones who knew what it was like.
Around this time, I started to have dreams I could barely remember and that left me physically exhausted, as if in them I ran great distances. Once, I woke with a bloody scrape on my left knee. I showed it to Gabe: the scrape glittered red under my desk lamp, as if it were not a wound but a jewel I had been given. I attributed the dreams to sex, both their physical manifestations and their psychological features. I was always exploring a space I never had beforeâwalking across an empty room or through an unfamiliar forest. There were never other people, but sometimes, there were animals. In theforest I saw squirrels whose rustles of movement startled me, but I was most afraid of a cat in the unfamiliar room. It was a small creature, silky and mustard colored and not overtly intimidating, but I felt loathing when I saw it. Often, the cat circled me or pushed against me with its head. Now I think my aversion had more to do with my resentment at being left alone in the room than the cat itselfâprobably it could sense my fear and was trying to comfort me. But I felt strongly that some wrong had been done in putting me there, and I directed this bitterness at the only creature I could.
On the last night of the Thanksgiving break, Gabe and I fell asleep together: our legs braided, our chests stacked spoons. The next morning, though, I woke up alone. Iâm not sure how I knew he hadnât gone back to his own roomâcall it instinct or intuition, the last cry of the subconscious. Before I could convince myself otherwise, I shoved into my sneakers and yanked on an old sweatshirt, grabbing a flashlight on the way out of the dorm.
It was cold outside, wind sighing in the trees. Fog had turned the sky cottony, so it was difficult to see Kellerâs houseâonly its smudged outline, faint as the sunâs corona, before a scrim of trees. As I came closer to the house, I could hear the stream that ran behind it, making noises like little licks. I intended to go all the way to the garden, though I had no idea what Iâd do when I got there. But I didnât have time to decide, because Gabe walked right out of the front door.
âSylvie,â he said, stopping in front of me.
I was stunned. Even if I feared Iâd find him here, I hadnât actually expected it. Still woozy in that early-morning hour, I almost felt I was dreaming. I reached for him.
âNo, donât.â He stepped back. âYouâre not supposed to be here.â
âNot supposed to be here?â We were both whispering, though my voice was getting louder. âYou just walked out ofKellerâs house. I saw youâout of Kellerâs house . And Iâm the one whoâs not supposed to be here?â
âItâs part of theââ Gabe turned his head, and his eyes flickered to the left, as though searching for someone. âRemember what I told you, Sylvie. Itâs part . . .â
His mouth hung open for a few seconds, then closed. But before I could tell him that he hadnât told me anything, another voice came from the doorway.
âGabriel.â
Mr. Keller stood in the arch that led into the house. Keller didnât often appear among us students when he wasnât