tricking us, by making us think we have to work out which is the strongest, but actually there isnât an answer to that question. After all, if you think about it, water can put out fire, canât it? I think theanswer to which apple to leave is somewhere else in the riddle. Look at the fifth line: â
one stands alone
â. I bet thatâs a big clue. And look,â he pointed at the eighth line. âIt says, â
The answerâs in the grassy square
.â â
They looked outside at the square of grass. The dog was still asleep. âMaybe youâre right,â Finlay said uncertainly. âWell, thereâs air in the square, because thereâs air everywhere. And thereâs water from the fountain. There isnât fire or stone. Thoughâ¦â He frowned thoughtfully. âThere
was
stone when the dog was a statue. So, the only thing that isnât there is fire! Fire
has
to be the answer to the riddle!â
âNo, hang on. If fireâs not in the square, it
canât
be right!â Max protested.
âI reckon that bit of the riddle just doesnât make sense,â said Finlay impatiently. âLetâs ignore it.â
âYou canât just ignore a bit of a riddle,â Max argued. âRiddles donât work like that. Look, we have to think this through. We have to be logicalâ¦â
âPants to logic!â Finlay said. âItâs fire, Max!â He lunged forward. Max tried to grab his arm to stop him but this time he was too late. Finlayâs fingers closed around the apple with the stone symbol.
Crack!
There was a loud snapping noise.
âWhatâs that?â Max gasped as Finlay charged out into the courtyard with the apple.
âMy hands!â yelled Finlay, stopping dead.
Max stared. The apple was still golden but Finlayâs fingers were turning grey â grey and hard like stone.
âFin!â Max gasped as the grey stone spread up Finlayâs arms and down over his body.
Finlay tried to move towards him but he couldnât move. He looked at Max with horrified eyes. âIâmâ¦â His voice choked and stopped as his head turned grey.
He had turned to stone!
CHAPTER SEVEN
THE CHERUBâS TRUMPET
âNo!â Max yelled. Finlay stood in front of him like a stone statue. The golden apple glittered evilly in his hands.
A great wave of sickness welled up inside Max. Finlay couldnât be stone!
He walked unsteadily towards the statue of Finlay. âFin,â he whispered helplessly. He felt dizzy with shock.
What was he going to do? What were Finlayâs mum and dad going to say?
He looked into Finlayâs grey face. With a gasp he jumped back. Finlayâs eyes were still normal!
âWhat-whatâ¦â he stammered as Finlay looked at him frantically, his eyes darting from side to side. âYouâre not dead!â Max exclaimed, relief hitting him like a sledgehammer.
Finlay couldnât say anything â he couldnât speak or move.
Maxâs thoughts whirled. He touched Finlayâs arm but it was as cold and hard as a stone pillar. Finlay might not be dead but he really
had
turned to stone!
What am I going to do?
Max thought.
Help!
A savage snarl rang out.
Maxâs gaze flew to the grassy square. The dog was lifting its heads from the floor. Its six burning eyes fixed on him and an even louder, more vicious growl ripped through the silence.
Silence!
Maxâs heart sank.
The batteries of the keyboard must have finally run out.
Barking furiously, Cerberus leapt to his feet and charged towards Max and the stone statue of Finlay.
Max leapt back just in time. The beast was pulled up short just in front of Finlay. One set of jaws crashed closed around Finlayâs leg. As its teeth met the rock-hard surface, the dog howled in pain. Its sleep didnât seem to have done anything to improve its temper.
Max ran forward. Finlay might be