maybe olderâbut not much olderâhe was wearing a satin kind of jacket like a sports jacket like high school boys wearâI think thatâs what I sawâI couldnât remember the color of the jacketâmaybe it was darkâdark purple?âa kind of shiny materialâa cheap shiny materialâmaybe there was some sort of design on the back of the jacketâOh I couldnât even remember the color of the vanâit was as if my eyes had gone blindâthe colors of things had drained from themâIâd seen everything through a tunnelâI thought that the van driver with the knife was dark-skinned but not âblackâ exactlyâbut not whiteâI mean not âCaucasianââbecause his hair wasâwasnâtâhis hair didnât seem to beââNegroid hairââif that is a way of describing it. And how tall he was, how heavy, the police were asking, I had no idea, I wasnât myself, I was very upset, trying to speak calmly and not hysterically, I have never been hysterical in my life. Because I wanted to help the police find the man with the knife. But I could not describe the van, either. I could not identify the van by its make, or by the year. Of course I could not remember anything of the license plateâI wasnât sure that Iâd even seen a license plateâor if I did, it was covered with dirt. The police kept asking me what the men had said to each other, what the pedestrian had said, they kept asking me to describe how heâd hit the fender of the van, and the van driverâthe man with the knifeâwhat had he said?âbut I couldnât hearâmy car windows were up, tightâI couldnât hear. They asked me how long the âaltercationâ had lasted before the pedestrian was stabbed and I said that the stabbing began right awayâthen I said maybe it had begun right awayâI couldnât be sureâI couldnât be sure of anythingâI was hesitant to give a statementâsign my name to a statementâit was as if part of my brain hadbeen extinguishedâtrying to think of it now, I canâtânot clearlyâI was trying to explainâapologizeâI told them that I was sorry I couldnât help them better, I hoped that other witnesses could help them better and finally they released meâthey were disgusted with me, I thinkâI didnât blame themâI was feeling weak and sick but all I wanted to do was get back to Princeton, didnât even telephone anyone just returned to the Holland Tunnel thinking I would never use that tunnel again, never drive on West Street not ever again.
Â
In that late winter of 1980 when Rhonda was four years old the story of the stabbing began to be told in the Karr household on Broadmead Road, Princeton, New Jersey. Many times the story was told and retold but never in the presence of the Karrsâ daughter who was too young and too sensitive for such a terrifying and ugly story and what was worse, a story that seemed to be missing an ending. Did the stabbed man die?âhe must have died. Was the killer caught?âhe must have been caught. Rhonda could not ask because Rhonda was supposed not to know what had happened, or almost happened, to Mommy on that day in Manhattan when sheâd driven in alone as Daddy did not like Mommy to do. Nothing is more evident to a child of even ordinary curiosity and canniness than a family secret, a âtabooâ subjectâand Rhonda was not an ordinary child. There she stood barefoot in her nightie in the hall outside her parentsâ bedroom where the door was shut against her daring to listen to her parentsâ lowered, urgent voices inside; silently she came up behind her distraught-sounding mother as Madeleine sat on the edge of a chair in the kitchen speaking on the phone as so frequently Madeleine spoke on the phone with her wide circle of friends. The most