She looked at him with those big blue eyes. Were they wet? Was she on the verge of tears? He studied her mouth. No pouting downturn, no indication that she was going to turn on the waterworks.
David sighed. He was paranoid already.
âYouâre scared to tell me,â she said.
âDamn straight, Iâm scared,â he admitted.
Katie ran her fingertips over his chest. She pulled at his nipples. David moved in the bed and one of her hands went down his belly, to where his cock was starting to show its appreciation. She stroked slowly and within seconds he was at full attention.
âYouâre going to fuck me into it, arenât you?â he asked.
âProbably.â
That was the thing about Katie. She had no hidden agendas, because she had no problem telling him exactly what those agendas were. Half the time it showed on her face anyway. She couldnât play poker if her life depended on it.
âYou wonât like me when I tell you,â he murmured. She wasnât paying much attention. Her mouth was descending on his cock.
She took her time, licking every inch and every ridge. She swirled her tongue around his head. She probed that sensitive spot underneath. He tried to think about baseball but all that came to mind was that one self-proclaimed slut who loved to have things pushed inside her, who loved to be stretched, and the time she looked at his aluminium baseball bat and asked him to fuck her with it.
âYouâre thinking about those other women, arenât you?â
It wasnât an accusation. Rather, it sounded hot as hell. Katie was breathless. She looked up at him with bright eyes and a wicked smile. Her tongue snaked out to lick the head of his cock. Any lie right now could get him into even more trouble than the truth surely would, and he knew it. Being honest was the lesser of two evils.
âYes.â
âOne in particular?â
This was getting rather uncomfortable. His heart was pounding, whether from arousal or from fear he wasnât sure. âWhy?â
âYou have that look.â
âWhat look?â
She sank her mouth down on his cock. All the way. She did that thing with her throat and then his cock was all the way in, her nose pressing right against his pubic bone. She could make him do anything when she did that. She was the only woman who had ever had that kind of power over him, and suddenly he wasnât sure he liked it. Soon he would be confessing like a good Catholic boy to a goddamn priest.
âOne in particular?â she asked again.
âYes.â
âWhich one?â
âJesus Christ, Katie! What difference does it make? Iâm not with her!â
âYouâre with me, and I want to know.â
David lay back and yanked a pillow over his head. He breathed deep into the cotton. Katie was working magic on his cock again, gliding up and every so often going all the way down, enclosing him in that slick, tight throat. She made deep-throating seem like a fine art. It hadnât come easily, though. She had practised on him again and again and again until she got it right.
Oh, did she ever get it right.
âTell me,â she murmured around his cock.
David pushed the pillow away from his face. If she really wanted to know, he would tell her. Maybe just one little thing. Maybe that would be enough to make her stop asking. He felt as though he were giving her an intentional knife wound as his mouth opened and the words came out.
âI was thinking about the woman who liked it when I put things inside her.â
Katie paused in the midst of sucking him. This would be it. Surely she would stop and lie down and be mad at him for a few days and then this would all blow over.
âWhat kind of things?â
David stared at the ceiling. âBottles. My hand.â He paused. âBaseball bats.â
Katie sucked him hard. It was a surprise, and he arched up into her mouth. She deep-throated him,